“Palestinians Have Been Denied Their Homeland”: S Jaishankar

“Palestinians Have Been Denied Their Homeland”: S Jaishankar


In a strong statement on the Israel-Palestine issue, External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar said that whatever the rights and wrongs in the whole conflict between Israel and Palestine, the underlying fact is that the Palestinians have been denied their rights and homeland.

He stated that what transpired on October 7 was a ‘terrorist attack’ but also acknowledged, in reference to the Israeli counteroffensive in Gaza, that every response must take into account something called international humanitarian law.

Mr Jaishankar, who is on a visit to Malaysia, was interacting with the Indian community during an event.

“How different pulls and pressures can be. On one hand, what happened on October 7 was terrorism. On the other hand, nobody would countenance the death of innocent civilians. Countries may be justified in their own minds in responding, but you cannot have a response that…every response must take into account something called international humanitarian law,” Jaishankar said.

“The fact is whatever the rights and wrongs of the issue, there is underlying issue of the rights of the Palestinians and the fact that they have been denied their homeland,” he added.

Hamas launched a horrific terror attack in Israel on October 7 killing more than 1200 people and holding more than 250 people as hostages, out of which over 100 are still in captivity.

In response, Israel launched a strong counteroffensive in the Gaza Strip targeting the Hamas units. However, the operation has also resulted in civilian casualties. According to Gaza ministry, more than 32,000 people have been killed in Gaza including women and children.

Notably, PM Modi was one of the first global leaders to condemn the horrific terror attack on Israel by Hamas on October 7.

However, India has also continued with its weight behind the ‘two-state solution’ to the long-running Israel-Palestine conflict.

Meanwhile, Mr Jaishankar is on an official visit to Malaysia, followed by his visits to Singapore and the Philippines.

Earlier in the day, he called on Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim and expressed admiration for his vision aimed at fostering stronger ties between India and Malaysia. He also emphasised that this vision will serve as a catalyst for crafting a more ambitious agenda to advance the relationship between the two nations.

He also held a round-table meeting with CEOs in Malaysia and appreciated their growing interest in partnering with Indian industries.

“A productive round-table meeting with CEOs in Malaysia. Glad to hear about growing interest in partnering with Indian industries. Encouraged them to join in India’s growth story. Discussed geopolitical developments that can provide more opportunities in business interactions,” the EAM posted on X.
 
India would have already acknowledged hamas as terrorist organisation, had it not have the impact of making the gulf countries angry. Indian govt has carefully built good ties with the gulf countries in last 10 years.
 
Palestinians should start making ghar wapsi by switching to Judaism or Christianity or their oldest religion prior to 3000 years.
 
Sad to see an esteemed diplomat monkey balancing with a civilization's struggle to survive and a rapine band of cultists, that despite an inherent history of terrorism and barbarity continues to cry foul when meted out a proper response.
 
Palestinians don't deserve any homeland. Lies and deceit are what they excel at. State of Palestine didn't even exists as a country but rather as a vassal state of Romans, Islamic Conquerors, Ottomans and then British Empire. Ancient communities of Phillistines, Moabs, and Amonites no longer exists and their whereabouts is unknown. What we see today is Arabs who doesn't not even originate from Palestine.
 
No, I vehemently disagree. Israel has to look this through to the end. Yes, civilian casualties are very unfortunate and saddening, but there really isn't any other viable solution.

If Israel pulls back now, they essentially go back to Square 1, and in a few years, the Hamas terrorists will do the same thing again.

Moreover, if Israel pulls out now, what message does that send to other terrorist groups? Pull all the nonsense you want, and when the other side hits back, hide among civilians. Once a few thousand civilians have paid the price for the terrorists' actions, they would be assured of the world coming to assist them, calling everything a genocide.

So, no. Palestine may have been denied their home, but Israel has, on multiple occasions, offered a favourable status quo. If the Palestinian people, egged on by Hamas terrorists, do not want such a solution and instead feel the way out is to attack Israel, then Israel's response is reasonable.

Play stupid games, win terrible prizes. It is as simple as that. A message needs to be sent to such terrorist groups, and Israel is sending it. We need to support them in doing so.
 
What is the difference between Judaism and Islam?
Plenty:
  • Judaism and Christianity both worship Yahweh (actual God), where Islam worships "allah" (Old Nick aka wannabe usurper -- Isaiah 14:14)
  • seen easily in dietary laws -- Judaism forbids camel and rabbit, both allowed by Islam
  • Judaism never called for global jihad
 
There was no Palestinians existed before, just like the Pakistanis..These Halalzyada nomad race came to existence when they multiplied like pigs , They are the Rohingyans of the middle east Pest Race ! No homeland existed as theirs ,, nor they do need one ,
 
What is the difference between Judaism and Islam?
Centuries ago, a spiritualist named Md wanted to become a ruler, emperor, and influencer to satisfy his own urges. He attempted to study Judaism, but at that time, Jews were not united among themselves, with many different schools of thought. Consequently, successive neighboring empires ruled and oppressed them. Md, being a shrewd person, lost hope in Judaism as a basis to satisfy his longing to become an emperor. So, he carefully hatched a plan to declare himself a prophet and start his own religion by mixing the teachings of the Torah with his own ideas and appropriating the prophets of the Jews. Original Judaism is a powerful religion, but it is mostly limited to Jews, not outsiders; therefore, Judaism does not believe in a global Jihad. So, Judaism didn't spread much.

Islam exist by appropriating Judaism religion. In reality, Islam came into existence only during the time of Md. But as I told before, Islam is all about Lies and Deceit, so it claims that Adam and Eve is the first Muslim. Before Md, Arabs in the pesinsula were all Pagan or Animists.
 
Plenty:
  • Judaism and Christianity both worship Yahweh (actual God), where Islam worships "allah" (Old Nick aka wannabe usurper -- Isaiah 14:14)
  • seen easily in dietary laws -- Judaism forbids camel and rabbit, both allowed by Islam
  • Judaism never called for global jihad
Both Al-Lat and Al-Lah are female and male deities from pre-cultist Arabia. Pedophet just appriopriated Allah for his schizophrenic hallucinations.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
2,983
Messages
17,853
Members
763
Latest member
Sinan Cagrı Kurt
Back
Top