Rohingya Lack Fundamental Right to Reside and Settle in India: Govt in Supreme Court Case

Rohingya Lack Fundamental Right to Reside and Settle in India: Govt in Supreme Court Case


The Indian government has presented its arguments before the Supreme Court regarding the status of Rohingya Muslim migrants currently residing in the country. The government maintains that these migrants lack the fundamental right to reside and settle in India.

The government’s argument centers on the separation of powers between the judiciary, legislature, and executive branches. They assert that the judiciary cannot dictate legislative or policy matters related to immigration, which falls under the purview of Parliament and the executive.

The government expresses concern about the potential security ramifications of a continued Rohingya presence in India. They cite intelligence suggesting some Rohingya are involved in obtaining fake identification documents, human trafficking, and subversive activities. Furthermore, they highlight the ongoing issue of illegal immigration from a neighboring country (Bangladesh) that has already impacted the demographics of certain Indian border states.

The Rohingya people are a Muslim ethnic minority who have faced persecution in Myanmar. Many have fled to neighboring countries, including India, where their legal status remains uncertain.
 
Proud of this government for taking such a bold stand. Secondly does the judiciary have this right to get involved in matters related to security.
 
Deport all illegals...Only Indian citizens via their lawmakers can decide who enters and lives in Bharat - period.
 
The supreme court should not have admitted any case requesting settlement of the d@ngerous r@hin-gaya jeh@di infiltr@tors who were driven out by peace loving My@nmar buddh!sts due to the violent separatist movement started by these rahin-gayas in the R@khine province. Let the 56 musl!m countries take them. We already have our own jeh@dis who are f@stbreeding, burdening our economy and causing law & order problems.
 
Rohingya are already settled in India lol. Govt should give a timeline of when they will be deported to bangladesh.
 
Never vote for fools who support Sibals and Singhvis. These parties can sell country
 
If this supreme court judge are so concerned settle this rohingyas into their house, please don't dump this extra garbage in my country, we already facing population issues.
 
Proud for taking this stand against these jihadi groups and reminding the judges what are their primary job and what all r their authorities. Just poking their nose everywhere is not good for judiciary.
 
If the Supreme Court favours settlement of Rohingyas then sent 10 Rohingyas each in the house of Supreme Court judges as charity begins at home.
 
In case Govt should get more bold and fight for their right. Court has no right to poke their nose in anything just based on 1-2 leftiest mindset.
 
Under no circumstances should these troublemakers be allowed to settle in India. India is under no obligation to accommodate these people permanently. At the earliest this lot should be sent back to wherever they belong. Out! Out!
 
If the Supreme Court favours settlement of Rohingyas then sent 10 Rohingyas each in the house of Supreme Court judges as charity begins at home.
The judges will be fine with that. Whether their wives will be happy, I don't know. Perhaps the Rohingyas can satisfy them.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
3,407
Messages
33,630
Members
2,044
Latest member
ku.nj727
Back
Top