Amid DRDO's Nirbhay-Based SLCM Delays, European MBDA's NCM and Russia’s Kalibr Compete for Indian Navy’s Interim Solution

Amid DRDO's Nirbhay-Based SLCM Delays, European MBDA's NCM and Russia’s Kalibr Compete for Indian Navy’s Interim Solution


The Indian Navy is actively evaluating advanced submarine-launched cruise missiles (SLCM) from European and Russian suppliers to equip its submarine fleet with a crucial long-range strike capability.

This move comes as the indigenous SLCM program, developed by the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO), faces a timeline that extends towards the end of the decade, creating a need for an interim, proven system.

Recent reports indicate that European consortium MBDA has offered its Naval Cruise Missile (NCM), also known as MdCN, for the Indian Navy's consideration.

This proposal places the NCM in direct competition with Russia's Kalibr cruise missile, which was proposed earlier. Both systems are being considered to fill a critical operational gap and enhance the deep-strike potential of India's current and future submarines while the domestic Nirbhay-based missile continues its development.

The NCM from MBDA is a naval version of the well-known SCALP-EG air-launched cruise missile, engineered for high-precision attacks on strategic land targets. The missile, which weighs 1,400 kg, can be launched from submarines to strike targets up to 1,000 km away and from surface ships up to 1,400 km.

It features a sophisticated guidance system using GPS, terrain-mapping, and an infrared seeker for terminal accuracy.

Its effectiveness has been demonstrated in combat, notably in April 2018 when French frigates used it in strikes against chemical weapons facilities in Syria, and again in a coordinated frigate-submarine launch in April 2024.

The combat-proven status of the NCM presents it as a reliable, off-the-shelf solution for the Navy’s immediate requirements.

A key advantage of the NCM is its compatibility with the 533 mm torpedo tubes used on India’s Kalvari-class (Scorpene) submarines. This makes it a strong candidate for the Navy’s next-generation Project 75-India (P-75I) submarines, where MBDA is already partnered with Mazagon Dock Shipbuilders Limited (MDL).

Meanwhile, Russia has put forward its 3M-14 Kalibr land-attack cruise missile as a direct competitor. The Kalibr system, which has been extensively used by the Russian Navy in conflicts including Syria and Ukraine, boasts a strike range estimated between 1,500 and 2,500 km.

The Russian proposal is reportedly part of a larger defence package that could include leasing a nuclear-powered attack submarine (SSN) and upgrading India's existing Kilo-class fleet.

The existing familiarity of the Indian Navy with Russian Kilo-class platforms offers a potential logistical advantage for integrating the Kalibr system. However, geopolitical factors, including Western sanctions on Russia, have raised questions about future supply chain reliability.

Parallel to these foreign procurement efforts, the DRDO is advancing its own indigenous subsonic cruise missile based on the Nirbhay platform. This missile is being designed for launch from standard 533 mm torpedo tubes and has a projected range of 1,000-1,500 km.

The DRDO’s Aeronautical Development Establishment (ADE) is leading the project, which has seen successful tests from an underwater pontoon, including a 402-km flight in November 2024.

However, the path to full operational induction for the indigenous SLCM is lengthy. The complex process of integrating the missile with a submarine and conducting extensive user trials means it is not expected to be ready for deployment before 2030.

This extended timeline has compelled the Indian Navy to explore foreign alternatives to ensure its new P-75I submarines, expected to enter service around 2031, are equipped with a credible land-attack cruise missile capability from day one.
 
I trust that the Navy is buying this foreign missile only to serve as a placeholder until a domestic missile is available. The Navy is committed to indigenisation.
 
The Russian offer seems to be the quicker route, besides Indian Navy has experience with Kilo class from a long time. The French offer can only be for Scorpene class and not naval ships as most of our modern fleet is primarily equipped for Russian weapons and would require large costs to integrate.
 
Maximum indigenous systems are in development or trial for many years now... Just take the example of Astra Mk1... I am hearing about Astra Mk1 trials for the last 4-5 years... I mean, what the fuck is our DRDO doing... Neither our private players can make missiles nor is DRDO completing projects on time, and that is why our forces are buying from foreign countries... They don't have any option... They need to counter threats....
 
Firstly, it makes no sense to compare a product under development (SLCM) with commercialized products like Kalibr and the Scalp. Even after 3 testings the range achieved so far far for SLCM has been around 403 km, which indicated that there is long way to go in development. DRDO is saying 5-7 years for development. Given its history of delivering, one can be reasonably sure that it will be another 10 years to commercialization. If we have the threat perception, we would need to move ahead with alternatives to SCLM on an immediate basis.
 
Maximum indigenous systems are in development or trial for many years now... Just take the example of Astra Mk1... I am hearing about Astra Mk1 trials for the last 4-5 years... I mean, what the fuck is our DRDO doing... Neither our private players can make missiles nor is DRDO completing projects on time, and that is why our forces are buying from foreign countries... They don't have any option... They need to counter threats....
The Astra MK1 is already inducted in service and MK2 will start service too. Also MK3 will take some time because by the time we complete the Super Sukhoi program it will almost be like a new jet so it’s better, easier and quicker to just integrate it after it’s upgraded.
 
Currently we already use the Russian Kalibr missile on the Kilo class submarines and their torpedoes. There are different versions and ranges in service.

The main weakness is the lack of a long range torpedo launched cruise missiles on the Kalvari class submarines as there’s no VLS available so until we develop our own missiles we are stuck on just using the Exocet missile which gives us a range of only 50km. Ironically these are the latest and most advanced stealth submarines but with a weak weapons package. The only alternative is to buy a small number of the new SLCM from France until we complete developing our own alternative.

However we should start to look at developing and installing our own hypersonic missiles because subsonic or cruise missiles can get intercepted much more easily. So ideally we need to develop both hypersonic and subsonic missiles because not ever target would be protected by SAM so we can use a cheaper and cost effective subsonic missiles.
 
Another stop Gap Purchase
I’d say get both systems, — the way things are moving means Russia situation could worsen even if deal is reached tomorrow, so JV/local production is necessary, similarly MBDA could be arm-twisted into sanctioning when capability is truly needed. Here again trying to get local production would be key.

We have lots of missiles, no harm keeping two more while India’s own comes of age. The knowledge gained from both systems could actually be useful. India is good in missile tech, so absorption would be no issue.
 
What is the rush? The naval version Brahmos is sufficient to scare any potential threat. If DRDO is working on something like that then let them do it. Nobody in IOR can challenge Indian Navy including submarines from China. We need big allies if anybody like USA threatens India.
 
India already operates Kalibr/Klub missiles.

The first 3 of the Talwar class actually never got the Brahmos on time and they use those missiles but in the export variant with limited range.
 
Russian stuff is battle proven , so opt for it.
I think Russian SLCM cannot be fitted on our western submarines like scorpeans and upcoming U boats.... only they can workfor kilos.... but kilos will be retired in coming 8 to 10 years....
 

Forum statistics

Threads
5,382
Messages
57,595
Members
4,087
Latest member
Raj009
Back
Top