How HAL's Nashik Facility Could Produce 14 Su-57E Jets Annually, a Significant Increase from Su-30MKI

How HAL's Nashik Facility Could Produce 14 Su-57E Jets Annually, a Significant Increase from Su-30MKI


Hindustan Aeronautics Limited's (HAL) Nashik facility, currently producing Sukhoi Su-30MKI fighter jets, could potentially be repurposed to manufacture the advanced Su-57E, the export version of Russia's fifth-generation stealth fighter.

According to Russia's state-owned defense conglomerate, Rostec, this transition could result in a significant increase in annual production capacity.

Rostec officials have stated that the Nashik facility, which currently produces 12 Su-30MKI aircraft per year, could be upgraded to manufacture 14 Su-57E jets annually. This represents a 16.67% increase in production.

This enhanced capacity is primarily attributed to the Su-57E's more compact design compared to the Su-30MKI, enabling more efficient use of the existing manufacturing infrastructure.

The key to this increased production efficiency lies in the dimensional differences between the two aircraft. Rostec provided the following specific comparisons:
  • Length: The Su-30MKI is roughly 8.76% longer than the Su-57E.
  • Wingspan: The Su-30MKI's wingspan is approximately 4.76% wider than the Su-57E's.
  • Height: The Su-30MKI is significantly taller, standing about 20.69% higher than the Su-57E.
These figures reveal that the Su-57E is smaller in all key dimensions. A composite dimensional comparison suggests the Su-57E is roughly 10.40% smaller overall than the Su-30MKI.

The most substantial difference, the reduced height, is particularly crucial for optimizing the use of vertical space within production hangars, potentially allowing for more concurrent work on multiple aircraft. The decreased wingspan and length also contribute to a smaller overall footprint, facilitating a more streamlined assembly line.

Rostec highlighted that the existing tooling and machinery at the Nashik plant, originally designed for the Su-30MKI, are largely compatible with the Su-57E's production requirements. This compatibility minimizes the need for extensive infrastructural changes, further contributing to the projected production increase.

It's also worth noting that the Su-57E, while incorporating advanced fifth-generation technologies like stealth and sensor fusion, may benefit from more modern, streamlined manufacturing techniques compared to the Su-30MKI. The Su-30MKI is a 4++ generation aircraft with a more complex design, including canards and thrust-vectoring engines, which potentially require more intricate assembly processes.

The Su-57 (Russia's domestic version, not the export Su-57E) is currently produced at the Sukhoi Komsomolsk-on-Amur Aviation Plant (KnAAZ) in Russia. According to publicly available reports, and confirmed by Rotec officials, KnAAZ delivered 14 Su-57s to the Russian Aerospace Forces (VKS) in 2024 and is scheduled to deliver 18 in 2025.

KnAAZ also produces the Su-35 fighter and previously manufactured the Su-27. The plant's proximity to operational units is considered crucial for providing ongoing support and specialist assistance for new aircraft.

The potential shift to Su-57E production at HAL's Nashik facility represents a significant development in Indo-Russian defense cooperation. While no formal agreement has been announced, Rostec's proposal indicates a willingness to deepen industrial collaboration and potentially offer India access to cutting-edge fighter jet technology. The feasibility and timeline of such a transition, however, remain subject to further negotiations and agreements between the two countries.
 
We must make Su-57E based FGFA/PMF and its hybrid engine here in India seeking 100% Tech with IP rights !
 
That will make 10 years to deliver 110 fighter jets, if selected under MRFA. Despite the Su-57 being smaller & only 89% the size of the Su-30 MKI, it has a more combat radius & heavy weapon carrying capacity. Even Dassault have a production rate of 13 for the Rafale, that makes plus one for the Su-57, which will have 14 per year & a long wait if Dassault failed to start in Bharat with a local Pvt. player with a complete eco-system where Dassault wants complete control over Rafale fighter jet production. Second, is autonomy to integrate sensors, weapons & future upgrades without OEM permission, that are the points to look for while choosing the fighter jet under MRFA/Make in India.
 
The Indian SU-57 must be M and not E. Initial 20 must be acquired off the shelf and the balance built with Transfer of Technology, including that of the IZ-30 engine. With source codes and full IP rights, India must then integrate Indian weapons, sensors, radars, and avionics in Indian-built aircraft.
 
I think if the government and IAF go like this, the slow fighter jet induction time will mean Pakistan will have more fighter jets than us.
 
India doesn’t want to buy the jet so it doesn’t matter how many planes the plant can make per year. What they need to do is allow the private sector to manufacture the Tejas jets.
 
The Nashik plant of HAL can be leased to Russia if it wants to use it for the production of Su-57. India does not need to buy either the F-35 or Su-57, as AMCA is getting ready.
 
That will make 10 years to deliver 110 fighter jets, if selected under MRFA. Despite the Su-57 being smaller & only 89% the size of the Su-30 MKI, it has a more combat radius & heavy weapon carrying capacity. Even Dassault have a production rate of 13 for the Rafale, that makes plus one for the Su-57, which will have 14 per year & a long wait if Dassault failed to start in Bharat with a local Pvt. player with a complete eco-system where Dassault wants complete control over Rafale fighter jet production. Second, is autonomy to integrate sensors, weapons & future upgrades without OEM permission, that are the points to look for while choosing the fighter jet under MRFA/Make in India.
Because it doesn't carry weapons outside and has more internal fuel more efficient engine supercruise.

Well the salt I mean Dassault has reached 36per yr production
 

Forum statistics

Threads
4,247
Messages
46,296
Members
2,927
Latest member
Sanjeev Kanwar
Back
Top