India Explores Domestic Production of Russia's Pantsir-S1 Air Defence Systems, Seeks At Least 50% Indigenous Content

Pantsyr-1024x661.jpg


India is exploring a partnership with Russia to domestically produce the advanced Pantsir-S1 air defence system, significantly bolstering its air defence capabilities. Bharat Dynamics Limited (BDL) Chairman and Managing Director, Commodore A Madhavarao (Retd.), confirmed that talks regarding local production are progressing positively. This potential collaboration builds upon decades of defence cooperation between the two countries.

The possibility of Indian production arose from a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) signed in November 2024 between BDL and Rosoboronexport, Russia's state-owned defence export agency.

This agreement, formalized during the 5th India-Russia Inter-Governmental Commission (IRIGC) subgroup meeting in Goa, outlines cooperation on different versions of the Pantsir, a mobile, short-range air defence system renowned for its adaptability and effectiveness.

The Pantsir-S1 is particularly notable for its combined missile and gun armament, enabling it to counter various airborne threats, such as aircraft, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), cruise missiles, and precision-guided munitions.

Developed by Russia's KBP Instrument Design Bureau, the Pantsir-S1 is a short-range, self-propelled air defence system designed to safeguard military installations, industrial areas, and key infrastructure.

Typically mounted on a mobile platform (like a KAMAZ or Ural truck), it features 12 surface-to-air missiles (57E6 or 57E6E) and two 30mm automatic cannons. This allows it to engage targets with missiles at distances between 1,200 and 20,000 meters, and with guns between 200 and 4,000 meters. It can engage targets from as low as 15 meters to as high at 15,000 meters in altitude, making it a versatile system.

A key characteristic of the Pantsir-S1 is its ability to engage up to four targets simultaneously, traveling at speeds of up to 1,000 meters per second.

It uses sophisticated radar systems (S-band and Ku-band) and electro-optical tracking, allowing it to function effectively even in environments with electronic warfare countermeasures, such as radar jamming.

Its quick reaction time and mobility are crucial for defending against modern air threats, as demonstrated in conflicts such as those in Syria and Ukraine. The system has a reported reaction time of 4-6 seconds.

Recent improvements, including the Pantsir-S1M variant, have boosted its capabilities. The S1M features enhanced electro-optical systems for both automatic and semi-automatic target tracking, an increased detection range of up to 75 kilometers, and an extended engagement range of 30 kilometers.

These improvements may be part of the ongoing discussions between India and Russia, as they work to customize the system to meet India's specific operational needs.

Reports indicate that the Indian Army is interested in a tracked version, potentially similar to the CADET (Carrier Air Defence Tracked) system, to provide air defence support for mechanized forces operating in various terrains, including plains, deserts, and mountains.

Some experts have cited that any deal will probably include at least 50% indigenous components. However, previous tests of wheeled variants in India reportedly revealed some mobility challenges. Addressing these issues and ensuring substantial indigenous content (aiming for at least 50%) are key priorities to fulfill India's specific defence requirements.
 
We need a lot of these as the war technique is changing. UAVs play the main role in any future wars. It's a great short-range air defense system and has played an important role in the Ukraine war. We should make these locally here.
 
The Pantsyr is a highly effective system, but all its parameters, radar, missiles, guns, range, EW capability have become an open secret due to the extensive use in Syria and Ukraine. The Israelis managed to knock out many of them. In turn, the Pantsyr managed to knock off many SPICE-guided bombs and other glide bombs in Syria, as well as cruise missiles.

It's really a high-tech weapon, and I wonder how the government babu-dominated BDL can absorb the technology if at all they give TOT, which I highly doubt. Just trying to solve the problem of vibration when the 2 x 30 mm guns open up, that affects the radar and the whole platform, and the software adjusting to that itself is a great obstacle to overcome. That's why the QRSAM radar vehicle has to come to a stop to fire its missiles, as we have not still mastered the algorithm for that.

Chinese EW snooping in the Ukraine and Syrian war would have picked up the radar signature. A Pantsyr was captured by Turkey from the LNA (Libyan National Army), and it was shipped to the US!! It's better we have our own Uttam AESA variant of the radar installed. The gun, the ammo, the missiles are all high-tech. I believe it's going to be another screwdriver assembly affair.
 
Pantsir is the most humiliated Russian air defence system in history. Multiple videos of it getting bombed in Ukraine, Syria, Iraq, and every other country that uses Russian equipment exist.

I even heard that once there was an article critical of the Pantsir system that was published in Russia, and the autocratic government of Putin suppressed it.
 
We have QRSAM. Why import Pantsir?

Plus, it failed in Ukraine.
In my opinion, Pantsir is one of the best self-propelled anti-air defence systems in the world. So, I would prefer this over QRSAM, not because I hate it, but just because Pantsir is superior, according to reports.
 
Nope - Not a freaking chance for this outdated system. The Pantsir-S1M failed in the Ukraine invasion left, right, & center. In the beginning, TB-2 drones destroyed dozens of Pantsir & Buk SHORADS in & around the Kyiv theater.

Then Pantsir-SM2 & Buk-M2/M3 were destroyed in scores by GMLRS & AGM-88 HARMs during the Kharkiv & Kherson counteroffensives. Moreover, Pantsir failed to defend against loitering munitions like Switchblade & Storm Shadow VLO AGMs in Crimea, Rostov, & even Smolensk oblasts.

There are serious deficiencies in all Russian air defenses, starting from Pantsir/Buk to S-300 & ultimately S-400 as well - It's just the Ukraine war made it crystal clear like never before. Previously, it was always poor crew training of Syrian/Libyan air defense crews & "downgraded export variants" - which were used as excuses to hide the failures. Now, we have the Russian military itself failing in Ukraine left, right, & center against export-grade weapons provided to Ukraine by NATO.

Anyway, India will not import any new weapon system from Russia anymore - that scope is over.

Our future MANPADS are going to be Stinger & V-SHORAD. Our short-range ADS are going to be QR-SAM & SPYDER/VL-SRSAM.

Our medium-range ADS will be MR-SAM & Akash-NG, while our long-range ADS will be S-400 & XR-SAM.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
4,304
Messages
44,121
Members
2,797
Latest member
Mc Addy
Back
Top