India Signals Keen Interest in Joining GCAP 6th-Gen Fighter Jet Program, But Encounters Japanese Caution Over Russian Defence Ties

India Signals Keen Interest in Joining GCAP 6th-Gen Fighter Jet Program, But Encounters Japanese Caution Over Russian Defence Ties


India has formally expressed its desire to participate in the Global Combat Air Programme (GCAP), a significant international effort by Japan, the United Kingdom, and Italy to develop a next-generation fighter aircraft.

According to reports citing diplomatic sources in both Japan and India, the Indian government has approached Japan to discuss joining the ambitious project, which aims to deploy an advanced stealth fighter jet by 2035. The GCAP initiative, established in December 2022, represents a major collaboration between the three founding nations.

However, reports suggest Japan harbours reservations about India's potential membership, primarily due to concerns that India's long-standing defence procurement relationship with Russia could compromise sensitive technology.

The GCAP seeks to create a sixth-generation combat aircraft equipped with cutting-edge capabilities, including enhanced stealth features, artificial intelligence integration, and advanced networked operations. This new aircraft is intended to replace aging fleets within the partner nations, such as Japan's Mitsubishi F-2 fighters and the UK's Eurofighter Typhoons (as part of the Tempest project lineage absorbed into GCAP).

Given the substantial development costs, estimated to run into tens of billions of dollars, the founding members are reportedly open to exploring partnerships to share the financial load and expand the potential market for the aircraft. India's involvement could offer significant benefits, including cost-sharing and access to its expanding defence industrial base.

Nevertheless, Japanese officials appear to be weighing the strategic advantage of potentially strengthening deterrence against China against the perceived security risks of technology transfer.

Japan's cautious stance is reportedly rooted in India's historical reliance on Russian military equipment. India's armed forces operate a significant inventory of Russian-origin hardware, notably the Su-30 MKI fighter jets which form the backbone of the Indian Air Force, and the S-400 air defence missile systems.

A senior official from Japan's Ministry of Defence was quoted expressing concern about the potential for sensitive GCAP technologies, particularly in areas like stealth, avionics, and propulsion, inadvertently reaching Russia through India. Furthermore, expanding the core group raises complexities regarding information security protocols and could potentially risk delays to the project's 2035 target deployment date.

From India's perspective, joining the GCAP aligns with its strategic goals. Participation could deepen defence cooperation with Japan, the UK, and Italy, strengthening partnerships viewed as important for stability in the Indo-Pacific region, particularly concerning China's growing influence.

It also directly addresses India's urgent need to modernise its air force. The Indian Air Force is currently grappling with a depleted squadron strength (reportedly around 31 squadrons against a sanctioned requirement of 42) and is pursuing its own indigenous fifth-generation fighter, the Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA), which is still in the development phase. Access to GCAP's cutting-edge technology could significantly accelerate India's capabilities and complement its domestic defence development efforts.

Interestingly, the prospect of India joining the collaborative fighter project is not entirely new. Previous reports indicated that both the United Kingdom and Italy were positively inclined towards Indian participation even before the formal GCAP agreement was finalised with Japan. It is understood that the UK had officially briefed India on the program, and Italy had also extended an invitation to explore involvement.

This earlier interest reflects international recognition of India's growing aerospace industry and its strategic importance. However, Japan's reported reservations introduce a significant hurdle that will need to be addressed in any future discussions regarding India's potential role in the GCAP initiative.
 
What will India's contribution be? How many of you have bought screwdrivers that were 'Made in India'? The most common tools found in Indian households are made in China. It's a fact! India has to develop its metallurgical industry towards the manufacture of high-quality tools and parts, be it for heavy machinery, tooling, precision engineering tools, aero and automotive engines, etc. We need to concentrate on quality like Germany and Japan and build a reputation as a source country for dependable, durable, and quality manufacturing. Then we will have something to offer.
No your factually wrong as our amount of exports are increasing and many companies are moving and securing their supply chain in India. More is getting manufactured in India then ever before.
 
That’s not really true. Our private sector companies have a lot of talent, knowledge and skills. The only problem is that they are not willing to invest their own money on key projects like jets, tanks, engines etc.

It was only after the private sector received funding for R&D for the WHAP, light tank, artillery etc from the government that they ‘magically’ found the talented, educated and skilled people to develop it when in fact they already employed those people anyway.
Tata WHAP uses American engine and transmission. It also uses a Russian turret with a cannon. Where is the "hidden" Indian talent?

Light Tank Zorawar's entire turret is Belgian. Where is the Indian talent? Engine and transmission is also American.

Dhanush is basically a copy of a Swedish gun. Where is our "innovative" talent?

We don't make anything that is challenging to build at all. And even if we build something, it's a copy or license manufacturing of someone else's product.

We have not innovated and showed the world something new and different that they have not seen before.
 
This will be a repeat of the FGFA. Better off sticking with the Russians and developing the Su-60 MKI.
Su-60MKI? What on Earth is that? You can't just randomly throw numbers around and create aircraft out of thin air.

Also, we've had the Russians try to fleece us over the FGFA project. No more, thanks.
 
Tata WHAP uses American engine and transmission. It also uses a Russian turret with a cannon. Where is the "hidden" Indian talent?

Light Tank Zorawar's entire turret is Belgian. Where is the Indian talent? Engine and transmission is also American.

Dhanush is basically a copy of a Swedish gun. Where is our "innovative" talent?

We don't make anything that is challenging to build at all. And even if we build something, it's a copy or license manufacturing of someone else's product.

We have not innovated and showed the world something new and different that they have not seen before.
The WHAP is only using a BMP 2 turret temporarily until Kalyani completes development of their new turret and gun. Also they will use the 600hp engine that DRDO is currently testing and once it passes it.

The zorawar will manufacture the turret from Belgium for the first 60 tanks and that will give them enough time for DRDO to develop the an indigenous turret and buy about 350. Also even when using the Belgium turret the indigenous content rate will be more than 70%.

Also the Dhanush is a heavily upgraded and better gun than what it originally was and while the overall concept might be similar the latest changes makes it a superior gun. Also we developed the ATAGS indigenously and orders have been placed with even more to follow.

So overall an attempt to indigenously develop advanced weaponry has been made and more orders will naturally fall in.
 
India should join the other 6th generation consortium- France/Germany/Italy. Better than UK/Japan
 
Japan's concerns are reasonable, and DRDO or HAL shouldn't be part of these negotiations. Frame the protocol to allow the pvt sector that meets this protocol as the project lead.
 
That's a good initiative and India must join the sixth generation fighter jet program while concurrently developing its own 5th generation fighter jet AMCA.
AMCA must come under direct control of PMO and induction should start from 2031-32 . Probable roll out in 2027-28. Now it's time to work in a mission mode.
 
Very true we need to join anyone of the European 6th Generation fighter aircraft pgme, since we are devoid of technology. Involvement of a Indian pvt firm with government funding in R & D work appears more logical with transparent dealings.
 
India should join the other 6th generation consortium- France/Germany/Italy. Better than UK/Japanno

India should join the other 6th generation consortium- France/Germany/Italy. Better than UK/Japan
Nope, that deal with france/germany/italy will not happen since their joint venture is bound to fail because of frances stubbornness to be seen as the leader of the venture and the difference in requirement for fighter jets by different members of the group. The only reason they haven't disbanded so far is that it would be a bad show of European friendship.
 
No your factually wrong as our amount of exports are increasing and many companies are moving and securing their supply chain in India. More is getting manufactured in India then ever before.
More of screws? When we crawl at Snail's pace, China is galloping away. All big talks about Atmanirbhar etc which is honey to the ears but beseached with indecision, lack of allotment of funds and continuing the beaurocratic pull back. When are we going to go ahead with a real purpose other than enriching certain specific individuals?
 
In my opinion, India should study the terms and conditions attached to the 6th gen fighter aircraft GCAP and participate in this programme.

There is so much to learn and gain in terms of knowledge and advanced technology involved in GCAP. If terms and conditions are favourable, GoI should not sit on the idea and drag it far too long.

We have failed in establishing R&D to produce homegrown advanced technologies. This wrong planning has caused several setbacks in our LCA programme, critically in homegrown formidable engine to power Tejas and thereafter advancing to AMCA and TEDBF.

The GoI should seriously consider this invitation to India to participate in GCAP and move fast. Of course, this participation involves money, but nothing comes free or cheap; we need to invest to obtain valuable advanced technology and knowledge.

We are struggling in certain critical areas in technologies; this has caused India to lag behind Turkey and S Korea, which are already much ahead of India. Just my thoughts.
 
Expecting an elephant 🐘 that slept for 60 years to run at top speed in 20 years appears to be ridiculous. Only by 2035 it can start walking provided the mahout remains the same
 

Forum statistics

Threads
4,575
Messages
49,043
Members
3,075
Latest member
ronaldo
Back
Top