Russia Pitches India's HAL as a Key Su-57E Production Partner for Global Exports, Hoping to Bypass Sanctions Amid Slow Sales

Russia Pitches India's HAL as a Key Su-57E Production Partner for Global Exports, Hoping to Bypass Sanctions Amid Slow Sales


In a significant strategic proposal, Russia is actively encouraging India to become a central partner in the production and global export of its Su-57E stealth fighter.

The offer, which goes well beyond a standard procurement deal, aims to establish India as a manufacturing hub, potentially revitalizing the fifth-generation fighter program that has been hampered by slow sales and international sanctions.

Moscow is reportedly prepared to send a technical team to India to further discuss this comprehensive partnership.

This ambitious proposal comes as Russia’s Su-57 fighter jet program faces considerable challenges. Developed by Sukhoi, the aircraft is Moscow's answer to competitors like the American F-35 and China's J-20.

However, the fighter's introduction into the Russian Aerospace Forces has been sluggish, with estimates suggesting only a small number of units are currently operational.

This slow domestic adoption, combined with production delays, has made international buyers hesitant, leading to a lack of export orders.

Furthermore, stringent Western sanctions, particularly the U.S. Countering America’s Adversaries Through Sanctions Act (CAATSA), have complicated financial transactions and technology transfers, pushing Russia to seek strategic alliances with non-Western powers.

The offer to India, which gained momentum at the Aero India 2025 exhibition, is multifaceted.

Russia’s state defence export agency, Rosoboronexport, has proposed an initial sale of 20-30 fighters, followed by licensed production at Hindustan Aeronautics Limited's (HAL) Nashik facility, which has a long history of assembling Russian aircraft like the Su-30MKI.

A key component of the deal is a full Transfer of Technology (ToT), including access to source codes. This would allow India to integrate its own advanced indigenous systems, such as the Uttam Active Electronically Scanned Array (AESA) radar and the Virupaksha sensor suite, creating a customized variant for the Indian Air Force (IAF).

The most groundbreaking element of the proposal is the offer of export rights. Russia is reportedly willing to authorize India to manufacture and sell the Su-57E to other countries. This marks a significant departure from previous collaborations, such as the Su-30MKI agreement.

While India successfully produced the Su-30MKI under license, its attempts to export the aircraft were largely unsuccessful as potential buyers often preferred to purchase directly from Russia.

By potentially turning HAL into a global supplier for the Su-57E, Moscow hopes an Indian endorsement will trigger a "domino effect," similar to how India’s large order of 272 Su-30MKIs boosted the aircraft's credibility and led to sales in over a dozen other nations.

For India, the proposal offers several strategic advantages. The IAF is currently operating with approximately 31 fighter squadrons against a sanctioned strength of 42, creating a critical capability gap.

The Su-57E could serve as a crucial stop-gap measure to counter the growing presence of advanced aircraft in the region, including China's J-20 and Pakistan's anticipated acquisition of the J-35.

The deal would also provide a major boost to India's "Atmanirbhar Bharat" and "Make in India" initiatives by enhancing its defence manufacturing ecosystem and supporting the indigenous Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA) program, which is expected to see its first flight by 2029.

However, the path to finalizing such a deal is filled with significant obstacles. The threat of U.S. CAATSA sanctions remains a primary concern for New Delhi, which has already faced complications over its purchase of the Russian S-400 air defence system.

Additionally, establishing a mutually agreeable payment mechanism for a multi-billion dollar contract in the face of international financial restrictions is a complex challenge.

There is also considerable skepticism within India's defence establishment regarding Russia's willingness to cede control over export markets, with officials seeking firm guarantees to avoid a repeat of the Su-30MKI experience where Russia continued to sell similar variants directly.
 
Get what's possible with some good missile, surely it must be better than that Chinese Stealth. Please move on ,spare the headache .
 
Ofc India should take this opportunity.

Su57 >>> Rafale
No doubt on it, so why does govt want to purchase additional 114 Rafale jets?

we can get su57 for cheap, and it's a much better stop gap from India's falling squadron strength, compared to rafale.

Indian Govt must purchase Su57.
(Who knows when TejasMK2 and AMCA will be in production?)

If we wait longer,
Our squadron strength will deplete further.
 
A mega Rafale order is coming as it seems. IAF and Government is now completely focused on that. Now I doubt that India will buy Su-57. India will buy a few S-400 and other systems, but Su-57 is unlikely. The biggest challenge will be the US. The US can target our service sector too if we sign a billion-dollar jet deal with Russia. Trump and Modi have signaled that things are again getting on track. If you follow MEA PC, they are very optimistic and want a more deep relationship with the US. Jet engines are still coming from the US, so India will not take a risk to hamper that. We have no option.
 
Very good opportunity. We must lap it up immediately before Russia changes their mind or the war ends. Russia now needs money and they are ready to provide us with their latest weapons. All Russian weapons are war-tested.
 


Purchasing SU-57s could jeopardize the GE engine deal, effectively ending the Tejas program and causing major delays for AMCA. To move forward with the SU-57, India would need significant leverage, such as facilitating an end to the Russia-Ukraine conflict or allowing the US to cross a key red line in trade.
 
It's a wonderful deal, I would say, since we will get complete TOT of a 5th generation fighter with complete rights & source code. Don't forget, the most complex thing in a fighter's development is its Engine, which is very complex to design.

If we receive complete TOT of AL-51F, then Indian defence industries will learn the know-how to develop a higher thrust engine of 150KN indigenously. This will contribute heavily to AATMANIRBHARTA. On the other hand, we get outrightly 50-60 fighters of the 5th generation.

The rest will be manufactured by joint collaboration between ROSOBORONEXPORT & HAL together in large numbers for our defence forces as well as for export. No other country will give you complete TOT of its fighter; remember, RUSSIA is our trusted & strategic partner.
 
It's definitely a lucrative offer and aimed at teaming up India with the Russia-China block. Well, I believe India will limit itself to being a consumer and avoid becoming an exporter. This is because if India supports Russian defence manufacturing on its own soil, it will have a direct and significant negative impact on India-US relations and to counter that we would need diplomatic muscle like China has, which we currently don’t have. So my view is that as of today India will likely buy Su-57 from Russia with local production and ToT, but the idea of becoming an exporter of this Russian bird will be kept on hold for the future.
 
India won’t go for this deal because of the sanctions on Russia and tariff war going on with the USA. India might start to manufacture some parts and components and export it to Russia so it reduces the cost per jet and make it more appealing for other buyers.
 
India is going to buy at least 2 to 3 squadrons of Su-57s as a stopgap until AMCA is ready. F-35 is junk and overpriced. We have a robust air defence system which can shield any incoming missiles or any generation fighter jets. We should never support US junks; rather, we should concentrate on indigenous, Russian, Israeli, or Japanese defence procurements. For American bootlickers here, F-35 has been in the news for some time. Hope you don't forget the Trivandrum airport incident and Japanese incidents. India is never going to believe the US anymore, and we don't want anything from them.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
5,613
Messages
58,949
Members
4,231
Latest member
Bmocethou
Back
Top