Opinion How Indigenous Upgrade of Jaguar Fleet Through HAL's ToT Could Have Partially Addressed the IAF's Squadron Strength Decline

file-qqk3jthehvepnkxnolcqe19b-webp.838


The Indian Air Force (IAF) has been grappling with a dwindling number of fighter squadrons, a concern that has persisted for years. While the recent retirement of the Jaguar strike fighter fleet was inevitable due to the aircraft's age, it also represented a missed opportunity to leverage India's indigenous capabilities to extend the service life of this capable platform.

The Jaguar, a joint Anglo-French design, has served the IAF well for decades. Its impressive performance and ability to carry a diverse weapons payload made it a valuable asset in various roles, including ground attack and reconnaissance. However, the aging fleet, coupled with spare parts shortages and maintenance challenges, ultimately led to its retirement.

A potential solution that could have breathed new life into the Jaguar fleet was a comprehensive modernization program. Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL), India's state-owned aerospace and defence company, possessed the Transfer of Technology (ToT) for the Jaguar, giving it the technical expertise to undertake significant upgrades. These could have included engine replacements, avionics modernization, and structural enhancements.

One crucial aspect of this modernization could have been replacing the original Rolls-Royce Adour engines with indigenous power plants. The Hindustan Turbo Fan Engine (HTFE-25), developed by HAL, was a promising candidate. This 25 kN turbofan engine with afterburner could have provided the Jaguar with enhanced performance while reducing reliance on foreign suppliers.

A revived Jaguar program could have also addressed the IAF's fighter aircraft shortfall. With a declining number of operational squadrons, inducting upgraded Jaguars equipped with state-of-the-art avionics, sensors, and indigenous engines would have offered a cost-effective solution to bridge this gap. Unlike procuring entirely new aircraft from foreign vendors, a Jaguar modernization program would have utilized existing infrastructure, supply chains, and technical expertise, reducing procurement timelines and import dependency.

Furthermore, a modernized Jaguar fleet would have been well-suited for specific operational roles, such as deep penetration strikes and maritime attack missions. The aircraft's proven ability to carry a wide range of weaponry, coupled with its robust design, makes it an ideal platform for precision strikes and low-level penetration in contested environments. With upgrades to its electronic warfare systems and radar, the Jaguar could have continued to play a crucial role in India's defence strategy.

The decision to retire the Jaguar fleet also has implications for India's aerospace sector. Building new Jaguars or significantly upgrading existing ones would have boosted HAL's manufacturing capabilities, particularly in domestic fighter jet production. It would have fostered collaboration between public and private sector firms in developing components, avionics, and engines, creating a vibrant defence ecosystem. Furthermore, this could have been a showcase project for exporting upgraded Jaguars to countries with similar operational requirements, expanding India's footprint in the global defence market.

By forgoing the opportunity to modernize the Jaguar fleet, India potentially missed a chance to bolster its air power, strengthen its domestic aerospace industry, and reduce its reliance on foreign suppliers. This decision highlights the complex considerations involved in balancing modernization needs with indigenous capabilities and strategic autonomy in defence procurement.
 
Today number of squadron doesn't matter any more, technology and quality matters. For eg 6 squadrons if LCA Tejas will be equal to single squadron of F35. So IAF needs to evolve its plans
 
Today number of squadron doesn't matter any more, technology and quality matters. For eg 6 squadrons if LCA Tejas will be equal to single squadron of F35. So IAF needs to evolve its plans
F35 seems to be prohibitively expensive, both aquisition & maintenance. Not sure, USA is ready to give them to India, a NON-NATO country.
 
Invest funding where? In developing engines for Jaguar or in buying old Mirage? Both platforms have less than a decade of life left. Will it be wise? It would be better to move on and buy a new platform to serve in the decades to come. Lastly, we need to show courage like when 21 MiG-29s were available at a throwaway price.
 
We should stop trying to convert mules to race horses. HAL and Modi govt have messed up the purchase of aircraft from abroad. HAL gave wrong assurances to rhe Govt. Whats the time line for MCRA TEDBA AMCA etc, are we going to tell the Chinese wait we arent ready for war. Who says 42 Squadrons, a 60s assessment when Chinese hardly had an airforce.We need 60 + now. The govt doesnt tell the country the truth about the state of affairs. Our security is highly jeopardized. Col.JP Singh
 
There is still time for HAL to revive HF-24 Marut. I mean producing Tejas in decent numbers is out of league for our HAL workers, at least they will be able to produce HF-24 in some decent numbers to fill the gap in our squadron strength.

Hopefully HAL will not face any issue getting Bristol Siddeley Orpheus Mk 703 turbojet engines for the Maruts, this time.
 
I think we should be more diversifying. Let US companies come to India with F-16 or F-21 production, which is a good piece for sale. F-15 or MiG-29, a forgotten hero, can still work. We must follow US and Russian weapon systems, as France will be lost with Europe being clueless in the world defense system. Jaguar and Mirage are now lost in history. Produce US or Russian weapons and sell them. Sadly, unless we have engine manufacturing, our fighter production will be just a showcase piece.
 
It's not the time to restore relics of the past or lament over missed opportunities to revive 4th-gen fighters.

China, Turkey, South Korea, and maybe even Pakistan have 5th-gen jets now.

The USA, France, Russia, Poland, Netherlands, UK, Japan, etc., also have the 5th-gen F-35 as a standard jet.

It is beyond doubt that we need 5th-gen too, and we cannot wait for AMCA, which is at least 10 years away from rollout or even its first flight.

The Rafale may be good, but it is 4.5-gen, and extremely expensive.

For every Rafale, we could have gotten at least 2-3 Tejas Mk1a, but we are even struggling with that.

Tejas Mk1a and Tejas Mk2 will be a decade too late already, if not more. We need 5th-gen and should work on 6th-gen, not early 4th-gen.

Not sure what we wanted the Jaguar revived for, maybe to fight wars against Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, the Maldives, or Nepal?!

We have the Tejas Mk1 for that, don't we?
 
We are already a decade, at least, behind in modernising our Air powers. God only knows when IAF will receive its next new fighter.. GOI should go ahead with GTG deal to buy at least 5-6 squardens as an security emergency and for once our political parties must come together on this, keeping the cheap politics aside..
 
The era of manned low flying fighters is long gone. Modern radars and integrated air defense systems are explicitly designed to counter precisely the very same tactic. With ubiquitous proliferation of MANPADS makes any aircraft making use of nap of earth flying to ingress into enemy airspace sitting ducks.

No.point in flogging a dead horse, let the platform retire. It gave a fairly good service and now time to let it go.
 
The jaguar is not fit for modern combat at all. It’s underpowered, has very few hard points, not as accurate, it can’t use modern weapons, technology is very outdated and its capabilities are severely diminished.

The last modern upgrade that we did was the DARIN 3 upgrade and overhaul the equipment and technology completely. By now they should have started to retire the jets but the delays with Tejas MK1A and MK2 means that we have to keep them in service.

The jet is not entirely useless because if we have to bomb a target where there’s no air defence, jets, drones, SAM or VSHORAD in the vicinity then these are good enough to destroy the target.
 
We should stop trying to convert mules to race horses. HAL and Modi govt have messed up the purchase of aircraft from abroad. HAL gave wrong assurances to rhe Govt. Whats the time line for MCRA TEDBA AMCA etc, are we going to tell the Chinese wait we arent ready for war. Who says 42 Squadrons, a 60s assessment when Chinese hardly had an airforce.We need 60 + now. The govt doesnt tell the country the truth about the state of affairs. Our security is highly jeopardized. Col.JP Singh
But there are reasons to not support the jets from other countries -

1 . Spare parts
2. Weaponry
3. Training facilities etc .

If you remember Rafale-M was proposed to come with Indigenous made Uttam AESA Radar but proposal was cancelled by Navy because it would take more time.

We are planning to integrate Indigenous weapons on Air force Rafale's but we cannot do it by ourselves due to restrictions from Dassault Aviation .

Also coming to timeline TEDBF and AMCA first flight will be from 2028 and coming to Defend our borders from PLA Air force we have Akash missile system, S-400 system.

But yes we are in dire need to modernize our Air force
 

Forum statistics

Threads
3,398
Messages
36,852
Members
2,362
Latest member
Varin11
Back
Top