India Should Procure Rafale Jets in Phases, Not in Bulk under MRFA due to Rapid Change in Fighter Jet Tech: Former Air Marshal

RafaleMeetRafale-India.png


Former Vice Chief of Air Staff (VCAS) of the Indian Air Force (IAF), Air Marshal Anil Khosla, has recommended a phased approach to procuring Rafale fighter jets, rather than a bulk purchase under the Multi-Role Fighter Aircraft (MRFA) tender.

This advice, given during a recent podcast appearance, echoes earlier suggestions by former Chief of Defence Staff General Bipin Rawat and former Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar.

The core of Khosla's argument lies in the rapid advancement of fighter jet technology. A staggered acquisition of Rafales would allow the IAF to capitalize on upgrades and new systems incorporated with each batch, keeping India's fleet at the forefront of aviation technology.

He cautioned that procuring all 114 jets at once, as stipulated in the MRFA tender, could result in a portion of the fleet being technologically outdated by the time the final deliveries are made. By phasing the purchase, the IAF could integrate the latest avionics, sensors, and weaponry with each new batch of Rafales, ensuring the fleet's long-term relevance and modernity.

This approach aligns with the views of General Bipin Rawat, who advocated for a staggered procurement strategy to alleviate the financial burden and prevent the IAF from being locked into older technology. Rawat emphasized the need to prioritize upgrading existing squadrons and gradually expanding the fleet, ensuring future acquisitions reflect the latest advancements.

Financial concerns were also raised by former Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar, who highlighted the potential strain the MRFA tender's estimated $20 billion cost could place on other vital defence programs. He argued that such a significant investment in a single program could lead to delays or even cancellations of other high-priority defence projects. India's defence budget must address various needs, including modernizing the Army and Navy, bolstering cyber capabilities, and investing in indigenous platforms under the “Make in India” initiative.

Recent reports indicate that the new Air Chief may be receptive to a phased procurement strategy, potentially bypassing the MRFA tender in favor of additional Rafales. This interim solution would allow India to continue its collaboration with Dassault Aviation, building on the success of the initial Rafale deal, which has already significantly boosted the IAF's operational capabilities.

Given the Rafale's proven strategic value in exercises and operations, expanding the existing fleet might be a more practical approach than waiting for the MRFA deal, which could take over five years to finalize.

Furthermore, a phased approach could circumvent the lengthy procurement process associated with the MRFA tender. The MRFA process is expected to be time-consuming due to multiple layers of bureaucratic approvals, budget allocations, and international negotiations. An interim procurement would allow the IAF to address its immediate operational needs while maintaining flexibility in future fighter jet acquisitions.

Another critical concern with the MRFA tender is its potential impact on India's indigenous fighter programs, such as the Light Combat Aircraft (LCA) Tejas and the Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA). India has made substantial investments in these projects, and diverting significant resources to the MRFA could hinder their development and production. A phased Rafale procurement would enable India to balance foreign acquisitions with continued support for its domestic platforms.

In conclusion, the phased procurement of Rafale jets presents a pragmatic solution to India's immediate and long-term defence requirements. It addresses the need to modernize the IAF's combat fleet while mitigating the financial risk of a large upfront purchase. This strategy also allows India to retain flexibility in its defence procurement, ensuring each batch of jets is equipped with cutting-edge technology.
 
Phased purchase will take per unit cost up and would not let you bargain for mid life upgrades and indigenous weapons and radar integration.
 
The big disadvantage in this approach is high per unit cost & no TOT as well as local production. The advantage is latest version will be available & Bharat can divert some funds to enhance the indigenous programme.
If Bharat is focused on this approach indigenisation will get a big support off course only if alternative production lines are in there in private sector. There is no point in this approach if only HAL is involved.
 
Bharat doesn't have money for any foriegn fighter jet. Be content and speed up development of Tejas mk1A,2,3,AMCA, ORCA and kaveri engine 2.0. Being a former chief he should know this.
 
The big disadvantage in this approach is high per unit cost & no TOT as well as local production. The advantage is latest version will be available & Bharat can divert some funds to enhance the indigenous programme.
If Bharat is focused on this approach indigenisation will get a big support off course only if alternative production lines are in there in private sector. There is no point in this approach if only HAL is involved.
true, we could have got 126 rafale in $20 billion with local production in 2016 now we are going to pay same amount for 72 rafale with 100% import.
 
One thing positive abt MRFA.. All experts, ex-experts, columnist, couch warriors, all are having a field day to express their expertise in defence field.. huge endless scope to showcase defence IQ.. Sit back & keep enjoying..🤘
 
true, we could have got 126 rafale in $20 billion with local production in 2016 now we are going to pay same amount for 72 rafale with 100% import.
100% import will never happen & we would have saved a lot more if the contract was signed in 2006.
 
Max we can buy consider 2 more sqn considering the investment and spending done for the India Specific expenses and the infra created for 4sqn.

Cancel the MRFA and for the more nos of sqn minimum 15 sqn for MK1a, MK2, Kaveri Twin Engine based ORCA and AMCA.
 
Phased purchase will take per unit cost up and would not let you bargain for mid life upgrades and indigenous weapons and radar integration.
Buying 114 at one go will allow ToT & Local mfg with Pvt players plus Eco-system , second as per MRFA Bharat will get Autonomy for Integrating weapons sensors system on its own without permission of OEM, Bharat upgrade older batches of Rafale as an when needed , Bharat have already developing GaN based AESA Radar unlike France yet to stat work on & will integrate in F5 version , bharat can integrate same GaN base AESA Radar on Rafale, Difference between HAL & Dassault clearly seen Dassault needs 8 years for Testing , certify & Integration of Uttam Aesa Radar while HAL will do it in less time on Su-30 MKI virupaksha AESA Radar on GaN with 1800 to 2400 TRM , Rafale can also Integrated with Third party weapons apart From Brahmos-NG, Rudram Family ( France lacks Anti-Radiation Family ) Dassaulyt charge heavy amount for ISE while Even Pvt players can do it in less amount Moral of the story Dassault charge hefty amount for any Specific improvement & take too much Time while HAL/Pvt players can do it in leass amount & less Time .
 
true, we could have got 126 rafale in $20 billion with local production in 2016 now we are going to pay same amount for 72 rafale with 100% import.
72 Rafales for 20 billion dollars? Any source for that figure, considering it will be second tranche which won’t require training and ISE and will reduce the quantity of spares as well.
 
Only if France can deliver 26 RafaleMs and 36 Rafale 4.2 guaranteed before 2030, with a G2G deal, with enforceable penalties let us buy them and scrap MRFA…In any case IAF chiefs are there for 1-2 years so really unsure of how they feel or can actually change policy…
 
France is running huge backlogs in delivery of Rafale jets. Even if India purchases 2 more sqadrons, it will be 2028-2030 before we get them. By then Tejas MK-II will be ready to induct in large numbers. It will be indeginious and upgradable as and when we want, and, at half the price the French charge. Forget MRFA. By 2035, AMCA will also be joining the IAF fleet.
 
India could buy another 36 rafale jets but there is a backlog of orders from other countries. Also we need to buy about 26 at the very least for our navy so we will be waiting at least 5 years or more before they all arrive.
 
Well better to have 72 5th gen fighters than having 114 4.5 gen anyhow 4.5 will become obsolete as 6 th gen enters after 5-6 years from now
 
I recall reading when the Rafales arrived here that there is a modular concept adopted for future upgrades.
Is it true or I misunderstood it?
 

Forum statistics

Threads
3,501
Messages
35,759
Members
2,224
Latest member
Indian patriot
Back
Top