Russia Proposes S-500 Co-Production and ToT for India, Aiming for A Strategic Export Hub to Bypass Western Sanctions

Russia Proposes S-500 Co-Production and ToT for India, Aiming for A Strategic Export Hub to Bypass Western Sanctions


In a major strategic move, Russia has reportedly offered its most advanced S-500 'Prometey' air defence system to India under a government-to-government (G2G) agreement.

The proposal is said to include full Transfer of Technology (ToT) and opportunities for co-production within India, building upon the existing defence relationship strengthened by India's acquisition of the S-400 'Triumf' system.

This offer represents a mutually beneficial arrangement.

For Russia, partnering with India provides a creative pathway to navigate the stringent economic sanctions imposed by Western nations that have restricted its state-owned defence companies from operating freely in the global market.

By enabling India to co-produce and subsequently export the system, Russia can maintain its presence in the international arms trade.

For India, the deal aligns perfectly with its 'Make in India' initiative, aimed at fostering indigenous defence manufacturing and technological self-reliance.

A Generational Leap in Air Defence​

The S-500 Prometey, developed by the Russian state-owned enterprise Almaz-Antey, is a next-generation surface-to-air missile system. It marks a significant upgrade over the already formidable S-400.

The system is engineered to intercept and destroy a wide array of aerial threats, including intercontinental ballistic missiles, hypersonic cruise missiles, and stealth aircraft. Uniquely, it also has the capability to engage satellites in low Earth orbit.

With an estimated anti-aircraft engagement range of up to 600 kilometres and the ability to track and destroy ballistic missile threats up to 500 kilometres away, the S-500 provides a far-reaching defensive shield.

Its advanced radar and interceptor missile technology, such as the 77T6 missile, allows it to engage targets flying at extremely high altitudes of up to 200 kilometres, offering a robust defence against current and emerging aerospace threats.

Building on Proven Success and Addressing Regional Threats​

India's interest in the S-500 follows the successful induction and deployment of its S-400 systems, for which a $5.43 billion deal was signed in 2018. The Indian military has operationalised these systems, referred to locally as the "Sudarshan Chakra," along its sensitive northern and western borders.

Reports indicate that during "Operation Sindoor" in May 2025, the S-400 was instrumental in countering aerial threats from the Pakistan Air Force, including modern JF-17 and J-10CE fighter jets.

The push for even more advanced systems like the S-500 is driven by the evolving security landscape in the region.

India faces a complex threat environment, including China's development of hypersonic weapons like the DF-21D and DF-26 missiles and Pakistan's expanding arsenal of ballistic and cruise missiles.

The S-500 would complement India's existing multi-layered air defence network, which includes the S-400 and the indigenous Akash missile systems, creating a more comprehensive and resilient shield.

A Strategic Partnership for Manufacturing and Exports​

The proposed co-production model would see India manufacturing key components of the S-500 system, including its complex radar arrays, command-and-control centres, and interceptor missiles.

This would not only boost India's domestic defence industry but also position the country as a potential export hub for this cutting-edge technology.

Russia appears to view India as a dependable partner capable of marketing the system to friendly nations in regions like Southeast Asia, the Middle East, and Africa, which may be hesitant to purchase directly from Russia.

This collaborative framework could insulate Russian firms from direct sanctions while helping India expand its own defence export portfolio, which has recently seen success with sales of the Pinaka rocket system to Armenia.

While India remains interested in procuring two additional S-400 squadrons, this new S-500 proposal presents a long-term vision for the India-Russia defence partnership, addressing both immediate security needs and future industrial ambitions.
 
Build a consortium and place it under it, or that Orange Orangutan in the west will impose sanctions on us.
 
Good, I was the first to say S-500 Joint Local production. With this offer, chances of F-35...?? when UK can be avoided in AMCA Engine development partner, being close to US, and instead France has been preferred. Hope it is not a contradiction in buying a 5th Gen Fighter jet.
 
Lmao, I had said this earlier too. Russia is kinda desperate to sell us any tech we want from them; they need investment partners like India to expand their production. This is a once-in-a-lifetime golden chance for us to take a technological leap, let's see if we grab it.
 
Do it like Brahmos, make an entire separate company and build this under that company name in India. That way, it will be an Indian product.
 
Excellent decision by the government, if true. Mass production of S-500 in India is the need of the hour to address the critical shortfall in squadron strength. It's clear by now India will not be able to match Chinese jet production in the next 20 years. Mass production of the S-500 is the only solution. For each Chinese jet and AWACS, there should be 10 S-500 missiles.
 
Producing S500 at home does not make any sense because it could hamper our own Kusha development. We just need 2-3 systems to fill the gap until Kusha gets ready for deployment. I think in coming days we could see some mega defence deals for the IAF.
  1. 60 Rafales from France in Make in India concept
  2. 40-50 F35s from the US under a G to G deal
  3. Additional S400s/S500s from Russia
  4. Additional 97 units of Tejas
 
We must go for a 100% TOT & IPR agreement for both S-400 & S-500, as these can serve as rapidly deployable, highly mobile defence (AD) with ABM capability, to fill in the gaps in our own BMD. The technology can be used and, if needed, modified to integrate into our existing AD networks, especially LRTR or SWORDFISH. Specific components may be developed into standalone AD systems for domestic use & export. A ship-based limited AD/BMD can also be deployed. The TOT cost may therefore be partially offset through some export sales.

We are at a crucial juncture; we must take this opportunity to gain usable technology from still top-notch Russian systems. Not everybody needs Western tech immediately; our focus must be on meeting our immediate needs in an economical & time-bound manner.

We are more or less sorted in radar tech, controls & software, Comm & EO/IR, but engine technology, or more widely various propulsion technology, is our Achilles' heel. Variable cycle & 6th-gen etc. can wait; as of now and for the next 10-12 years, we need various jet engines: 3-5kn for cruise missiles; 25-45kn for HALEs, UCAVs & trainers; 95-120kn for Tejas-like single-engine point defence interceptors; 120-160kn for AMCAs, TEDBF/ORCA & high-performance stealth variants of Tejas, or non-stealth similar to F-16s; 160-220kn for possible long-range bombers, stealth or otherwise; 70-180kn high-bypass variants for medium & heavy transport aircraft; marine propulsion units for larger ships; 1500-2000kw turboshaft engines for heavy helicopters & turboprop aircraft.

Looking at various hurdles in gaining Western engine tech and to hedge against the possibility of deliberate delays, we must take a three-pronged approach, i.e., increased & immediate research funding for local 90-120kn Kaveri derivatives, French JC 120kn push on strict timelines, and 100% TOT for Russian Project 177s & Iz-30 engines.
 
I would rather buy another 2-3 S-400 squadrons and make them in India rather than buying S-500. And I would fully focus on the indigenous Kusha and its future upgrades to the S-400 to S-500 level. These costly Make-in-India programs, with almost no ToT, will only help Russia and stall all our indigenous programs. The government needs to stop these screwdriver 'giri's.

Every private company is getting into these without any R&D and I guarantee you, even after 20 years of manufacturing like PSUs and DPSUs, these private companies will not invest a single rupee in any R&D. The government needs to stop these programs if they really want to focus on real Atmanirbhar.

We already have anti-ballistic defence systems which are in service and we are making Project Kusha. Once these projects' R&D is complete and production starts, approve money for Kusha 2 with a higher range and higher accuracy. Stop looking at every other country for products.
 
I think the S-500 is not an immediate requirement. What we need are cheap air defence systems which can neutralise hundreds of high-altitude drones together. The Chinese are developing high-altitude swarm drones and they can provide them to anyone.
 
First buy fighter jets. The S400 is still going to protect India for the next 10 years. Plus we are yet to get 2 squadrons which will be deployed along China border. Plus India has a very strong layered Air Defense system comprising of L70-Akash-LRSAM-S400 currently.

What we need immediately is modern fighter jets!! We are very much short of them. Buy 6-8 squadrons of F-35/SU-57M/Rafale immediately. HAL is years behind production so no sense beating that monkey and Tejas Mk1A cannot stand up to 5th gen fighter jets!!
 
No doubt that the S-500 is a formidable weapon, but the billion-dollar question is how long we will chase the S series, starting from S-100, 200, 300, 400, and now the S-500. Based on our past experience, we should now focus on indigenous systems, i.e., Kush. Provide this huge money in R&D for systems like Kush. As of now, the S-400 is enough for our defence purpose.
 
DRDO is progressing well with Project Kusha and we do not need S 500 anymore. Perhaps, instead of 2 pending S 400, Russia can deliver S 500 and finish it off.

If India starts producing and exporting S 500, USA can put sanctions on India too!! So this logic for India buying and then exporting S500 does not work.

We are quite capable in radar and missile technologies and let us rely on our own strengths.
 
Lots of potential deals are there in the making and are seen progressively only in media corners . No substantial/ official news are there from the GOI or MoD, ofcourse it has been the trend of India where nothing or very less comes in the print or visual media pertaining to defense procurements. In a way that is good perspective considering the surprise elements that our Armed forces always wish to have. IAF chief AP Singh Sir in his recent address, was very open in a closed manner where the great achievements by IAF in Op Sindoor were disclosed in a very professional manner maintaining the required secreacy of operations. But still in his address there were few moments or we can say some clues which does suggest lot of procurements are round the corner particularly for enhancing the strength of Indian Airforce potentially both from Russia and France. So just wait and watch after long and cumbersome wait lots of very good news for IAF are around the corner. Considering the high risk job of our Armed force they deserve best arsenal in their stock.​
 
For purchasing the S-400, Bharat wasted too much time to make the decision. Hopefully, this time around it will be sooner so as to avoid cost escalations and new sanctions which might be forced by the hypocritic Western nations. When Bharat purchased the S-400, I still recollect some of the commentators said it was a $5+ billion junk.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
5,283
Messages
57,067
Members
4,011
Latest member
Lady bug
Back
Top