AVNL Offers Customized Russian Sprut with T-90 Firepower for Indian Army's High-Altitude Light Tank Procurement, Challenging DRDO-L&T's Zorawar

AVNL Offers Customized Russian Sprut with T90 Firepower for Indian Armys HighAltitude Light T...webp


State-owned Armoured Vehicles Nigam Limited (AVNL) has partnered with Russian defence firms Rosoboronexport (ROE) and High Precision Systems (HPC) to propose a specially modified version of the 2S25 Sprut-SD light tank for the Indian Army.

This collaboration, announced in August 2024, aims to compete in India's procurement process for 295 new light tanks specifically designed for high-altitude warfare.

The Indian Army's quest for light tanks is proceeding under the "Make-I" category, emphasizing indigenous development and manufacturing.

AVNL's Heavy Vehicles Factory (HVF) in Avadi, Chennai, will lead the effort to tailor the Russian design to meet India's unique operational requirements in mountainous border regions, particularly along the Line of Actual Control (LAC) with China.

This puts the AVNL-Russia offering in direct competition with the domestically developed Zorawar light tank, a joint project by the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) and Larsen & Toubro (L&T).

Originally designed for Russia's airborne forces by the Volgograd Tractor Plant, the 2S25 Sprut-SD is technically a self-propelled anti-tank gun. It boasts a powerful 125mm smoothbore gun, similar in calibre to the main armament of India's T-90 main battle tanks, but mounted on a much lighter 18-tonne chassis.

The base model features amphibious capabilities, can be dropped by parachute, and is even capable of firing its main gun while floating. However, the Indian Army requires enhancements for sustained high-altitude operations, better armour protection, and modern electronic systems, necessitating significant modifications to the original Russian design.

The joint venture aims to blend Russia's established light tank technology, especially its gun system and amphibious features, with Indian-made components to increase the indigenous content, aligning with the government's #AatmanirbharBharat (self-reliant India) policy. AVNL and another Indian public sector unit, India Optel Limited (IOL), will hold a majority stake, ensuring Indian control over the project.

While the potent 125mm gun – capable of firing various ammunition types including anti-tank guided missiles (ATGM) like the 9M119 Svir – is expected to be retained, upgrades are anticipated in areas like the fire control system, electronics, and armour to defend against contemporary threats such as drones and advanced anti-tank weaponry.

The Ministry of Defence (MoD) has formally invited bids through a Request for Proposal (RFP) for these light tanks. HVF/AVNL is among the entities eligible to compete, provided they meet the technical and financial requirements.

To support its bid, HVF is already seeking suppliers for critical subsystems needed for the customized Sprut, including engine management units, auxiliary power units (APUs), integrated loitering munitions or drones, and advanced suspension systems crucial for performance and mobility in the thin air and rugged terrain of high-altitude environments.

The planned inclusion of drones and loitering munitions indicates an effort to match the advanced capabilities being integrated into modern armoured vehicles. The competing Zorawar light tank, for example, is designed with integrated surveillance drones and potentially an Active Protection System (APS) to counter incoming projectiles.

The base Sprut-SD's armour, reportedly sufficient only against heavy machine gun fire (12.7mm rounds), is a point of concern regarding battlefield survivability, suggesting significant upgrades will be necessary. Modifications to the suspension are also vital, as the original BMD-3 chassis-based design has faced criticism regarding stability when firing its large 125mm gun, particularly on uneven ground.

The urgency for these light tanks stems from operational gaps highlighted during the 2020 border standoff with China in the Galwan Valley region, where the Chinese People's Liberation Army (PLA) deployed its own Type 15 light tanks suited for mountain warfare.

Initially, India considered an emergency off-the-shelf purchase, potentially including the latest Sprut-SDM1 variant, but later opted for indigenous development under the Make-I rules.

The DRDO-L&T Zorawar, officially revealed in July 2024, has already passed initial milestones, securing a preliminary order for 59 units. Trials for the Zorawar are currently underway in both desert and high-altitude conditions.

The competition for the remaining 295 tanks remains open.

The Zorawar weighs around 25 tonnes and is equipped with a 105mm main gun (sourced from John Cockerill). It emphasizes modular design, artificial intelligence integration, and a high degree of indigenous content, powered by a 760 hp Cummins engine delivering a power-to-weight ratio of about 30 hp/tonne.

In contrast, the lighter 18-tonne Sprut-SD, with its 510 hp engine, offers around 27 hp/tonne but benefits from its amphibious nature and potentially easier rapid deployment. However, critics point to the Sprut's comparatively lighter armour and potentially older base design as disadvantages against the purpose-built Zorawar, which incorporates modern survivability features like APS from the start.

Other Indian companies like Kalyani Group, Tata Advanced Systems, and Mahindra Defence Systems, potentially partnered with foreign manufacturers, may also contend for this significant defence contract.
 
Good to have competition in Lightweight Tank too; the best will be selected which meets all parameters.
 
Abso-damned-lutely not! Russia can keep their junk Spruts, thank you very much. Why on Earth would AVNL even think about something like the Sprut, which has nothing beyond basic splinter protection in terms of actually protecting the tank and its crew? Heck, if all that wasn't enough, even Russia isn't particularly interested in the tank, with production seemingly stopped at 24 units with some proposals for mass production.

We have the Zorawar, which is a very promising and very decent light tank. Throw the Sprut out of the competition.
 
Been making tanks and armoured vehicles since like eternity. Yet can't even design a light tank independently. That is DPSU level of ingenuity.
 
Abso-damned-lutely not! Russia can keep their junk Spruts, thank you very much. Why on Earth would AVNL even think about something like the Sprut, which has nothing beyond basic splinter protection in terms of actually protecting the tank and its crew? Heck, if all that wasn't enough, even Russia isn't particularly interested in the tank, with production seemingly stopped at 24 units with some proposals for mass production.

We have the Zorawar, which is a very promising and very decent light tank. Throw the Sprut out of the competition.
Armour protection has never been a forte of Russian tanks. So much so that Soviet armour doctorine was built around large number of light tanks rolling through Ukrainian plains into central Europe in a pincer attack. The Russian philosophy rung around designing a machine fit for the job.
So much so that even their tank crew was selected around the machine instead of it being the other way round. A Russian tank crew had height and size restrictions to suit their tanks. In that chain of thinking, protection was designed around protecting the equipment. Crew protection was secondary.
 
Armour protection has never been a forte of Russian tanks. So much so that Soviet armour doctorine was built around large number of light tanks rolling through Ukrainian plains into central Europe in a pincer attack. The Russian philosophy rung around designing a machine fit for the job.
So much so that even their tank crew was selected around the machine instead of it being the other way round. A Russian tank crew had height and size restrictions to suit their tanks. In that chain of thinking, protection was designed around protecting the equipment. Crew protection was secondary.
Correct. The same is borne by Russian tank design as well, where you have the world-infamous carasouel shell ring in the turret for the autoloader. Well, the only decent purpose ot serves is that it keeps the sport of tank turret toss alive.

And now we have some bright spark in our defence development establishment who want a carasouel autoloader on the FMBT besides a standard autoloader.
 
With the requirement for the total number of light tanks being projected by the Indian Army, which is 295 as of now, even if we assume double the number and take it at approx. 600, does it make sense to have another contender to the indigenous Zorawar tank, that too a Russian tank?

Zorawar has been designed and prototypes are in operation, based on the order of 59 already placed, purely based on Indian Army requirements. So it is almost customized!

So what's the point in bringing in another product? Better to only license certain specific elements from Sprut-SD (if at all there are any elements deemed critical and missing from Zorawar) and move ahead only with an Indian option.
 
With the requirement for the total number of light tanks being projected by the Indian Army, which is 295 as of now, even if we assume double the number and take it at approx. 600, does it make sense to have another contender to the indigenous Zorawar tank, that too a Russian tank?

Zorawar has been designed and prototypes are in operation, based on the order of 59 already placed, purely based on Indian Army requirements. So it is almost customized!

So what's the point in bringing in another product? Better to only license certain specific elements from Sprut-SD (if at all there are any elements deemed critical and missing from Zorawar) and move ahead only with an Indian option.
Competition will always benefit bharat, it will increase productivity, efficiency, quality ad otoh will decrease the price.
On you emphasis on "that too a russian tank", IA only uses Russian tanks, do you believe these are inferior and thats why opted by IA?
 
Competition will always benefit bharat, it will increase productivity, efficiency, quality ad otoh will decrease the price.
On you emphasis on "that too a russian tank", IA only uses Russian tanks, do you believe these are inferior and thats why opted by IA?
My issue with AVNL is, they are not offering any "competition", they are trying put spanner into work by introducing a cheaper but inferior machine into the equation which won't add any value to Indian military industrial complex.

Mark my words, AVNL can go decades assembling this abomination without learning a bit about tank designing from the experience.
 
Seriously, why? It literally doesn't offer much protection and is basically a tin can. The tank is based on an old Soviet design which sacrificed protection for speed and firepower, as it was meant for quantity and less for survival, while the Zorawar offers a more balanced approach.
 
There is no need for any foreign tank when Zorawar has already met all the requirements and is undergoing trials currently.

The only advantage that the Sprut brings is its commonality with 125mm guns and ammo that it shares with the T-72/90, but even that is not a real advantage as the 125mm gun lacks the vertical elevation provided by the smaller 105mm cannon.

Since the Zorawar light tank already incorporates modern features, it should be inducted over the Russian tin can.
 
Ok, so final verdict is Zorawar is going to be a closed file soon😂😂
 
Absolutely not. The Russians are trying to extinguish indigenous efforts of the Indian pvt sector to protect themselves, and the AVNL are actively collaborating with them. Shame on them. Concentrate on the Arjun tank first, AVNL.
 
Competition will always benefit bharat, it will increase productivity, efficiency, quality ad otoh will decrease the price.
On you emphasis on "that too a russian tank", IA only uses Russian tanks, do you believe these are inferior and thats why opted by IA?
Combat operations all over the world has demonstrated that Russian tanks are inferior to Western systems, India has been fortunate that their systems have not been tested in combat and also Pakistan and PRC have inferior fleets as of now.
 
Zorawar only!!!

Also, why go for heavy tanks at all? Instead of de-armour the light, converting it into a "tank destroyer" (with weapons added equal in weight to the armour deleted).
 
The Sprut tank will not succeed at all because its armour is too weak even if they can improve and increase the armour, include machine gun, grenade launcher, ATGM, surveillance drones, kamikaze drones, anti drone system.
 
Why waste time on competition when you have already custom made Zoravar for it?

Just mass produce it to bring down the cost!
 
Why screw drive when we can design and produce our own. Take fast decisions and go for desi platforms.
Difference is 9 tons, that’s why, 27 tons vs 18 tons. Zorowar is mid weight tank, it is hard to air lift that much weight, that's the reason they are trying different options, the more lighter it is better, trying another option doesn’t mean it is selected, competition will make the local product efficient and cheaper and avoids monopoly like HAL.
 
Combat operations all over the world has demonstrated that Russian tanks are inferior to Western systems, India has been fortunate that their systems have not been tested in combat and also Pakistan and PRC have inferior fleets as of now.
Oh really, why Leopard and Challenger are burning.
 
Difference is 9 tons, that’s why, 27 tons vs 18 tons. Zorowar is mid weight tank, it is hard to air lift that much weight, that's the reason they are trying different options, the more lighter it is better, trying another option doesn’t mean it is selected, competition will make the local product efficient and cheaper and avoids monopoly like HAL.
ZORWAR can be airlifted by the current medium transport planes with IAF.
ZORWAR is accepted by the army after thorough study of its specifications.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
4,606
Messages
49,397
Members
3,096
Latest member
Sriharsha Hoysala
Back
Top