Embraer Proposes C-390M As A Unified Solution for India's MTA and AWACS Needs, Offering Faster, Cheaper Development Over Outdated ERJ-145

Embraer Proposes C-390M As A Unified Solution for India's MTA and AWACS Needs, Offering Faster, Cheaper Development Over Outdated ERJ-145


Brazilian aerospace firm Embraer has presented a strategic proposal to the Indian Air Force (IAF), suggesting its C-390M Millennium aircraft as a common platform for both its future Medium Transport Aircraft (MTA) and its next-generation Airborne Warning and Control System (AWACS) requirements.

This offer provides a potential solution to the significant hurdles the IAF faces in acquiring additional ERJ-145 jets for its Netra Mk1A surveillance program, as the aircraft has been out of production for over a decade.

The IAF's plan to expand its airborne surveillance capabilities, known as the Netra Mk1A program, has encountered major obstacles. The program intended to mount advanced Indian-made radar systems onto six second-hand Embraer ERJ-145 airframes. However, finding suitable used aircraft has proven difficult and costly.

The process of retrofitting these older jets involves extensive and expensive modifications to meet military standards, raising concerns about airframe condition, future maintenance, and the availability of spare parts for a platform that is no longer being manufactured. The estimated cost for this complex conversion project stands at approximately ₹9,000 crore (around $1.1 billion).

Embraer's C-390M Millennium is a modern, twin-engine transport aircraft and a primary candidate for the IAF’s MTA project, which aims to procure 60 to 80 new aircraft to replace the vintage Antonov An-32 fleet.

The C-390M is designed for versatility, capable of carrying a 26-ton payload and equipped with advanced features like a fly-by-wire flight control system.

The company's new proposal highlights that a specialised AWACS variant of this aircraft could be co-developed with India.

An AWACS aircraft, often called an "eye-in-the-sky," provides crucial surveillance and command functions during air operations. The C-390M's larger size and capacity would allow it to host more powerful and sophisticated mission systems developed by India's Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO).

Unlike the current Netra system on the smaller ERJ-145, which offers 240-degree radar coverage, a C-390M-based AWACS could feature a more advanced radar with 300 or even 360-degree coverage. It would also have greater endurance and space for more operator stations and enhanced self-defence suites.

This proposal strongly aligns with India's "Make in India" initiatives.

Embraer has already signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with Mahindra Defence Systems to establish a final assembly line for the C-390M in India if it is selected for the MTA contract.

This partnership would create a domestic hub for manufacturing, maintenance, and training, fostering significant technology transfer and boosting India's aerospace and defence industry.

Despite the apparent advantages, the IAF has not yet formally evaluated the C-390M for the dual transport and AWACS roles.

The Air Force's current preference for the ERJ-145 platform is based on fleet commonality, which simplifies logistics, training, and maintenance since it already operates several ERJ-145 variants.

However, the operational challenges and rising costs associated with sourcing and modifying obsolete aircraft present a compelling case for considering Embraer's modern, multi-role solution, which promises a faster development timeline, lower lifecycle costs, and superior capabilities to meet the region's evolving security landscape.
 
Good, add to that a tanker should be developed by Embraer too. One platform for multiple use from AWACS, transport, and refuelling tanker that will be a cost-effective measure for IAF with synergy and commonality in logistics/MRO/maintenance with local assembly with a complete eco-system.
 
First take two on lease for atleast an year or two and get it checked in every role like navy dud with predator drone.
If it suits get 100 TOT and manufacture it in India.
 
If there are better alternatives go for them. Let them feel the pinch for they just showed interest in Akash to push their products.
 
Brazil has decided not to buy Akash system, despite it's sterling performance in OpSindoor, and is going to buy some European system. India should also not go for this plane, and either seek some other alternative, or build its own.
 
The proposal seems very good, taking the future into account. It's also a backdoor method of the company trying to get the larger order for replacing the AN-32 or the IL-76. But my gut feeling is that going for the C-390 is better, as it is better to spread our risks. Moreover, we can bargain hard and get a good deal from Brazil, unlike the US or Europe, and get total ToT as Brazil is willing. It has to recover the investment it made.

The disadvantage is that it is going to take more time to convert the C-390. Brazil will be eager to do it as there will be many customers who will be impressed by the versatility of the C-390. It is a rugged airframe built to take harsh conditions, unlike the EMB-145 or the A-320 platform.
 
Indigenous AWACS await Netra Mk 1A and Netra Mk 2, suitable aircraft, modification of those aircraft for integration with sensors, final integration, and then certification. My assessment is that we will have Netra Mk 1A equipped EMB-145s in another five years and Netra Mk 2 equipped A-321s in another 10 years. There is an urgent need to procure three ISTAR aircraft (Bombardier 6000) from L3, as they are the market leaders after Raytheon withdrew from the market (post their failure in integration with the US DoD), and two SIGINT aircraft.
 
Indian over analysis breeds self doubts & invisible ghosts .... must consider JAPAN KAWASAKI be the way forward . Serves massive Anchorage & foray pe vast outcomes depth , plays & threads , unlike others Japan be solvent & smart . Suffice to say 🇮🇳 must unleash its focused approach serving its core & firming peripheral sinews .. Japanese needs & Indian outreach cannot be timed more perfectly..... lets Rock..Jai Mata di
 
India shouldn’t develop a brand new AWACS on the C-390 planes at all because it will increase the purchase cost, refurbishing costs, operating cost and create too many different MRO facilities from Russia, France, Israel or the USA to maintain etc.

We should definitely concentrate and buy more second hand ERJ 145 planes but install more of our indigenous and technology capabilities like radars, EW/ESM and a larger circumference radar range close to 360 degrees. At the same time we should upgrade our current ERJ 145 planes so we can improve its capabilities as well. We can still conduct ISTAR missions which are very crucial and important and we could increase and buy more ERJ 145 than the original six planes.

What we also need to do is quickly develop the 6 brand new AWACS planes based on an Airbus passenger plane. We need to install a longer range detection radar, increase the detection circumference, EW/ESM, ISTAR missions, longer flight time etc.
 
C390 AWACS for Netra Mk2 project? Because it is too big for Netra Mk1A, and the antenna will get masked by its high-mounted wings. Who has come up with this rumour? A321 is already earmarked for Netra Mk2.
 
Brazil has decided not to buy Akash system, despite it's sterling performance in OpSindoor, and is going to buy some European system. India should also not go for this plane, and either seek some other alternative, or build its own.
They didn’t buy it because we were not offering our latest version which is top secret and only available to Indian forces.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
5,093
Messages
55,817
Members
3,857
Latest member
Akshat Kumar Agarwal
Back
Top