Indian Army Faces Potential Manpower Crisis Amid Declining Inductions

The Indian Army is facing a potential manpower shortage as the rate of new recruits joining the force continues to decline, according to sources within the Department of Military Affairs (DMA). This shortfall raises concerns about the Army's ability to maintain its operational strength, particularly along critical border regions.

The Army's current induction rate, if not improved, could leave the force significantly below its required troop levels by the end of the decade. This is a significant challenge given the need for a strong military presence in regions like Eastern Ladakh, where India shares a contested border with China.


In 2024, the government introduced the Agnipath scheme, which aimed to address troop shortages by inducting young recruits for a fixed four-year term. However, the scheme has faced criticism and hasn't delivered the expected results.

One factor limiting recruitment under Agnipath is the age restriction, currently set at 17.5 to 21 years. The Army is proposing to raise the upper age limit to 23 years to attract a wider pool of potential recruits. Additionally, the military seeks approval to increase overall induction numbers to address the manpower gap.

Data released by the Ministry of Defence in Parliament earlier this year revealed significant vacancies across all three branches of the armed forces. The Army alone faces a shortage of over 100,000 personnel.

If approved, the proposed changes to the Agnipath scheme could be a step towards resolving this crisis. However, it remains unclear whether these adjustments will be enough to close the growing gap between required and actual troop strength.

 

[jason smith]

Not just army, there is shortage in pretty much every govt department.

 

[Kira]

This was bound to happen as earlier COVID restricted IA recruitment to a virtual standstill and then the Agniveer policy derailed it further and kept it that way.

 

[Rudra]

Youth not interested to become Agneeveer

 

[Mango_Indian]

I can speak from personal experience that many fit youngsters are taking up private sector security/loss prevention jobs rather than joining Agniveer scheme. Many private companies are advertising indirectly for candidates who clear Agniveer selection and offerring them jobs which better the pay and give long term stability. Media may not write on this not to offend 6ODI govt and invite retribution.

PM and President will buy 10,000 crore airplane for official use but clamp down salaries and benefits of entry level soldiers. Lets see how this benefits the nation.

 

[Boomeranger]

Now, Army MUST SIMPLY PUSH AGNIVEER 3 years Short Service Commission programs in all PUC-11-12th classes of all schools, in ALL universities & colleges throughout India; and also go to rural villages small townships and conduct awareness programs of military capacity of IA- all of the new weapons etc., and the urgent need to stop CCP PLA advances and need to stop Pork's terrorisms. Once aware, they will join in good numbers I believe so especially in poorer Bihar-Jharkand-Uttarakhand-MP-UP-Chattisgarh-Punjab-Rajasthan Jat Sikh villages wherein Madi-ji has destroyed all job opportunities for youth...

 

[Boomeranger]

I can speak from personal experience that many fit youngsters are taking up private sector security/loss prevention jobs rather than joining Agniveer scheme. Many private companies are advertising indirectly for candidates who clear Agniveer selection and offerring them jobs which better the pay and give long term stability. Media may not write on this not to offend 6ODI govt and invite retribution.

PM and President will buy 10,000 crore airplane for official use but clamp down salaries and benefits of entry level soldiers. Lets see how this benefits the nation.

all lies... Pvt sector NEVER offers permanent jobs. dey are always doing "hire-and-fire" only. Now, above 45 years aged all IT workers are getting fired for some flimsy reasons or the other... Short Service Commission AGNIVEER program is ideally suited for unemployed youth to get military skills and next, quit army after 3 years to start their own Security Guard Services next...

 

[Boomeranger]

This was bound to happen as earlier COVID restricted IA recruitment to a virtual standstill and then the Agniveer policy derailed it further and kept it that way.

thanks to Covid19 and a humongous rise in online and SIM scams even Aadhaar scams in India, nowadays youth want quick moneys by doing these scams only....

 

[Sandeep]

India recently inducted about 40000 of new recruits so there are many people who are joining the military. The biggest vacancies are in low paid and low skilled labour work, specialists, area deployment, officer shortages etc. There was a shortage before the Agniveer scheme started so the issue isn't with the scheme but they need to find ways to retain those soldiers after their service length is up.

 

[Sudha]

I can speak from personal experience that many fit youngsters are taking up private sector security/loss prevention jobs rather than joining Agniveer scheme. Many private companies are advertising indirectly for candidates who clear Agniveer selection and offerring them jobs which better the pay and give long term stability. Media may not write on this not to offend 6ODI govt and invite retribution.

PM and President will buy 10,000 crore airplane for official use but clamp down salaries and benefits of entry level soldiers. Lets see how this benefits the nation.

Are you even aware most of the defence budget is being used for pensions & salaries? There is hardly any funds for capital purchases. If the taxes are raised to fund capital military purchases people cry about high taxes. Bharat is spending on salaries & pensions of military personnel which is very high when compared to US defence budget.

 

[Mango_Indian]

all lies... Pvt sector NEVER offers permanent jobs. dey are always doing "hire-and-fire" only. Now, above 45 years aged all IT workers are getting fired for some flimsy reasons or the other... Short Service Commission AGNIVEER program is ideally suited for unemployed youth to get military skills and next, quit army after 3 years to start their own Security Guard Services next...

Yes…government of India offers “permanent “ jobs. See where HAL and NAL and everyone in other government jobs can get us.

 

[Mango_Indian]

Are you even aware most of the defence budget is being used for pensions & salaries? There is hardly any funds for capital purchases. If the taxes are raised to fund capital military purchases people cry about high taxes. Bharat is spending on salaries & pensions of military personnel which is very high when compared to US defence budget.

If you spend 2% of budget in defence and maintain 1.1 million army, what do you expect ?

Our eat-anything-that-moves neighbor spends 4% plus and our cut-pork-sausage neighbor spends 8%. We have been under foreign rule for 200 plus years and 13% of our population are traitors. What other threats do you need to increase defence budget ?

 

[Deans]

My blogpost on the Agnipath scheme.
https://rpdeans.blogspot.com/2024/06/agnipath-analysis-and-way-forward.html
I analyse the assumption behind the scheme and debunk them. In my view, the scheme in its current
form will not serve the intended purpose and will cause more harm than good. However, it an be made to work with some tweaks. I use data from other armies to make my points.

For those who have not seen my blog - I'm retired and independent. This is a non commercial blog where I use data to provide original analysis on areas I am interested in and not adequately covered
by the mainstream media. I blog on Indian national security, current wars (Ukraine and Gaza) and startups. All data is open source.

 

[Joshua26]

I analyse the assumption behind the scheme and debunk them. In my view, the scheme in its current
form will not serve the intended purpose and will cause more harm than good. However, it an be made to work with some tweaks. I use data from other armies to make my points.

For those who have not seen my blog - I'm retired and independent. This is a non commercial blog where I use data to provide original analysis on areas I am interested in and not adequately covered
by the mainstream media. I blog on Indian national security, current wars (Ukraine and Gaza) and startups. All data is open source.

Your study gives light on the scheme's failings and opportunities for improvement. It is evident that your independent viewpoint, backed with evidence from a variety of sources, provides a distinct and critical perspective on these issues. I enjoy how your site focuses on topics that are often ignored by mainstream media, such as Indian national security and current conflicts. Your commitment to leveraging open-source data for original analysis is admirable and adds much to the discussion. I am excited to explore your site and learn more about your research and viewpoints. Keep up the great work!

 

[Deans]

Thanks for your kind words. It's unfortunate that there is no fact based study in the media and the issue invariably pits veterans against those who echo the govt position, with either side getting to data.

 

[manov7]

Thanks for your kind words. It's unfortunate that there is no fact based study in the media and the issue invariably pits veterans against those who echo the govt position, with either side getting to data.

You are correct; the absence of research-backed reports in the media makes conversations more difficult and causes division. Encouraging open dialogue that takes into account all perspectives, including those of veterans, is crucial. Encouraging data-based conversations is essential to enhancing comprehension and identifying successful resolutions to current problems.

 

[oliver889]

Thanks for your kind words. It's unfortunate that there is no fact based study in the media and the issue invariably pits veterans against those who echo the govt position, with either side getting to data.

It’d be nice if we could get a bit more data-driven discussions where both sides can actually agree on something factual. But, sadly, it feels like that’s rarely the case

 

[Pati]

So it is better to ask related officers to find the real reason. the main reason is salary

 

[Pati]

The government would rather spend more funds, and budget to purchase foreign weapons than improve the welfare of its soldiers. this is the main reason. because they can earn a commission during purchase progress. but they can't get enough benefits on welfare field