Acquisition of US F-35A by India Could Shatter Chinese J-20 and J-35A Stealth Fighter Confidence, Says Former IL-76 Navigator

F-35-JSF_1440760.jpg


A former IL-76 navigator, Vaidya, has weighed in on the potential acquisition of the F-35A by the Indian Air Force (IAF), asserting that even a limited number of these advanced fighters could significantly undermine the confidence of pilots flying China's J-20 and J-35A stealth fighters.

"An F-35, despite end-user agreements and other operational conditions, will be enough to tilt the balance decisively in the IAF's favor across the border," Vaidya stated. He also dismissed the readiness of Russia's fifth-generation Su-57 and the conceptual Su-75 Checkmate, stating, "No matter what Russia claims, the Su-57 is far from ready for operational deployment, and the Su-75 is still just a paper plane until we see a prototype rollout."

Vaidya highlighted the F-35A's maturity as a platform, with its proven production line and continuous upgrades, making it the most advanced fighter jet available today. The recent Block 4 upgrades further enhance its capabilities with increased missile capacity and advanced avionics, transforming it into a versatile multirole combat aircraft.

"The F-35 is more than just a jet; it is an integrated combat system. Its annual production line ensures that spares and upgrades are readily available, making it a long-term investment in airpower," Vaidya emphasized.

He acknowledged that the U.S. would likely impose certain conditions for any F-35 sale to India, including operational separation from the Russian-made S-400 air defence system and an end-use monitoring system. These stipulations are standard practice for all F-35 operators to protect sensitive technology.

However, Vaidya pointed to Israel's successful customization of its F-35 fleet, known as the "Adir," which integrates indigenous weaponry and electronic systems. He suggested India could negotiate similar customization options to tailor the aircraft to its specific operational needs.

"The IAF should demand local integration of its weaponry and electronic warfare systems. Countries like Israel have demonstrated that this is not only feasible but also crucial for tailoring the aircraft to specific operational requirements," he added.

While the U.S. State Department has traditionally been cautious about arms sales to India, recent statements from Pentagon officials indicate a growing interest in including the IAF among F-35 operators. This shift aligns with Washington's strategic focus on countering Chinese influence in the Indo-Pacific region.

Acquiring the F-35 would be a significant leap for the IAF, providing a platform unmatched by regional adversaries. However, India must carefully weigh the operational benefits against the geopolitical and financial implications of such a deal.

"The F-35 is not just an aircraft; it's a strategic deterrent. If the U.S. agrees to the sale, the IAF will gain a critical edge, and the confidence of pilots flying the J-20 or J-35A will evaporate overnight," Vaidya concluded.

The prospect of India acquiring the F-35 remains speculative but increasingly plausible in the current geopolitical climate. For the IAF, the F-35A could be a force multiplier, solidifying its position as a dominant air power in the region. However, navigating the complex negotiations with Washington and balancing operational needs with the conditions attached to such a high-stakes purchase will be crucial.
 
If F-35 come without carrot and stick approach,we should welcome it otherwise not ! Better ask Dassault to make Rafales in India !
 
What a BULLSHIT,
US need an end-use monitoring system to track the Indian F-35 deployments (if India choose to buy), than it's a big red-flag. It is like giving back-door control access to US.

It will effectively compromise India's integrity and Strategic Autonomy. We are not puppets of US just like NATO countries, better develop our own AMCA.
 
First US have given very bad experience about Engines for Fighter jet , question over Reliability, second back stabbing ,another thing is kill switch
 
What a BULLSHIT,
US need an end-use monitoring system to track the Indian F-35 deployments (if India choose to buy), than it's a big red-flag. It is like giving back-door control access to US.

It will effectively compromise India's integrity and Strategic Autonomy. We are not puppets of US just like NATO countries, better develop our own AMCA.
Do you think they don't monitor currently, the moment you use GPS technology, they know where are you. All the guidance kit we are using are using GPS currently, NAVIC is still not operational.
 
It will be Dumb to Trust the US in any critical Defence deal..They have already shown their true colours by delaying the GE 404 and GE 414 Jet Engines which the US will Absolutely NOT GIVE to India just to teach India a lesson it was Stupidity of monumental proportions to believe the US on the Jet Engune deal..
 
Please develop AMCA latest by 2035. AMCA IS 5.5 GEN while F35 is 5th gen only. Dolandji will offer F35 to Bharat without any end user lisence because Dolandji has excellent relations with Modiji.
 
Two squadrons of F-35 and 70 Rafaels more would be the right answer for the enemy countries procuring the latest jets. As for the integration of different types of aircraft in our inventory it should not be a problem as we have been having Jaguars, Mirages alongside Mig 21s and others. Further if we are to move away from the Russian foothold in the selection of armaments it is best we slowly getting used to these from the US and other Western Countries.
 
There's no question that it is and that it would be the unquestionable stealth champ in the region at LEAST until Chinese 6th gen, and perhaps even then. American stealth is way ahead.

But...It's all moot if it's not formally asked for and offered. If there's no way to get the F35, we should reexamine Russia's claims with a modernized Su-57M instead of spending 20-30 billion on this fourth gen MRFA fiasco that has dragged on for decades. All I'm saying is reexamine their claims, if it turns out the Rafale F4 is still far more advanced that's fine, but it also costs more despite only trying for late fourth gen. With the rear radar blocker now and flat nozzles with airstreams integrated the Su-57M has clearly gone above any fourth gen on all aspect stealth if that package is ready soon.
 
Please develop AMCA latest by 2035. AMCA IS 5.5 GEN while F35 is 5th gen only. Dolandji will offer F35 to Bharat without any end user lisence because Dolandji has excellent relations with Modiji.
Just wait for 11 years of living though excuse making and delays. I bet we don't see a full squadron of AMCA MK1 until 2040 at the earliest. And by then China could be over 1000 J20s deep and flying sixth gen already.
 
F-35 modifications can be limited to SDR datalink integration. That will ensure quick induction without compromising capabilities.
 
First US have given very bad experience about Engines for Fighter jet , question over Reliability, second back stabbing ,another thing is kill switch
The kill switch is a myth. Do people really think smart countries like Israel that are no one's vassal wouldn't try to find such a thing. It's never been found, people only spread sketchy stories of Australians not being able to lock on to US targets, but even the French Rafale had a hard time locking onto an F22 within visual range so this was probably not a software lock thing.

Now who benefits from spreading rumours about US fighter jets...But even still, the Su-57M is the only fifth gen on offer for us.
 
Because roll-out/first flight ceremonies won't win wars. It will enter service only by 2035.

China already has 200+ J-20s and counting.
We will buy some 5th gen jet in limited quantities in the interim for sure but not F-35, I don't think GOI or IAF would agree to send all the mission data to LM servers all the time whenever they fly F35.
 
India should allow USA one base somewhere in the East for its F35s. As a part of the deal, IAF should allowed to use up to 3 squadrons during war times. This would be a win win deal for both, as the cost for USA to maintain such fleet will go down considerably and cost for India will be saved too.
 
The USA has categorically stated that they won’t sell the F35 jets to India. Even if we got rid of the S400 system then they still wouldn’t sell it to us because we asked for the USA SAM before purchasing the S400 and they refused. Also they aren’t prepared to transfer any of the critical technology so the USA only have themselves to blame as they had the opportunity but blew it.
 
We will buy some 5th gen jet in limited quantities in the interim for sure but not F-35, I don't think GOI or IAF would agree to send all the mission data to LM servers all the time whenever they fly F35.
TBH there is no need to buy 5th generation jets, unless AMCA face some hiccups, at least we should learn from our mistakes now...

Everytime Pak procured some jets or other systems from the west, we bought foreign system to tackle that due to that we did limited R&D because that money went to France, Russia for direct import..
 
TBH there is no need to buy 5th generation jets, unless AMCA face some hiccups, at least we should learn from our mistakes now...

Everytime Pak procured some jets or other systems from the west, we bought foreign system to tackle that due to that we did limited R&D because that money went to France, Russia for direct import..
Buying foreign 4th gen jet paying Billions in this era is so dumb and naive, AMCA won’t be inducted at-least till 2040 realistically looking at the 5th gen programs of advanced Countries and how long it is taking, I am not talking about novices South Korea or Turkey, so it is imperative that some foreign 5th gen jet needs to fill that void until that time comes for us, especially when the enemies surrounding India or operating 5th gen aircrafts.
 
The USA has categorically stated that they won’t sell the F35 jets to India. Even if we got rid of the S400 system then they still wouldn’t sell it to us because we asked for the USA SAM before purchasing the S400 and they refused. Also they aren’t prepared to transfer any of the critical technology so the USA only have themselves to blame as they had the opportunity but blew it.
US didn't refuse SAM. When they informed us about the price, Indian govt ran away. Rather they were very keen to sell it.
 
AMCA/FGFA will be ready by second half of 2028 according to ADA, then why we need F35
AMCA prototype is expected to roll out by 2028 not on Final operational status. You dont fight a war with prototypes. It takes a good 5 to 6 years or even more to move from Prototype to IOC TO FOC status.
 
US didn't refuse SAM. When they informed us about the price, Indian govt ran away. Rather they were very keen to sell it.
No this was during the Obama days. They only offered to sell it to us when Trump came into power but by then we had already assessed and negotiated a deal with the S400 and it was too late and expensive to buy the USA SAM.
 
We will buy some 5th gen jet in limited quantities in the interim for sure but not F-35, I don't think GOI or IAF would agree to send all the mission data to LM servers all the time whenever they fly F35.
If the conditions are duly agreed by us before signing the agreement, then why should we fear some data going to LM servers ?

LM doesn't gather any data which they don't pre-specify (mostly related to maintenance).
 
If the conditions are duly agreed by us before signing the agreement, then why should we fear some data going to LM servers ?

LM doesn't gather any data which they don't pre-specify (mostly related to maintenance).
Do you willingly agree to your neighbor to invade your families privacy by setting up cctv inside your house for him to watch what you are doing 24x7, this is something like that, you will loose your freedom.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
3,528
Messages
35,984
Members
2,241
Latest member
Mark Williamson
Back
Top