India May Initially Compromise on Localization for Faster Delivery of 114 Fighter Jets under MRFA Tender

MRFA-1.jpg


India's Ministry of Defence (MoD) is preparing for one of its largest defense procurements in recent years: the acquisition of 114 Multi-Role Fighter Aircraft (MRFA) for the Indian Air Force (IAF).

While the MoD is prioritizing rapid delivery of these jets, potentially aiming for 20-24 aircraft per year, sources suggest this ambitious goal may require a temporary compromise on India's commitment to local production.

India's defense policy, particularly under the "Make in India" and "Atmanirbhar Bharat" initiatives, strongly emphasizes self-reliance and domestic manufacturing. However, achieving high delivery rates for complex fighter jets often necessitates a mature production line and streamlined supply chain, which can be challenging to establish while simultaneously meeting ambitious localization targets.

Experts believe the MoD might initially lower localization requirements for the MRFA project, potentially setting them around 30-40% instead of the usual 70% target for major defense procurements. This approach would allow for faster delivery while providing Indian industries time to scale up and mature.

Demanding both rapid production and high localization from the outset could discourage Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs). Setting up local manufacturing for complex fighter jet components requires significant time and investment. OEMs might argue that such demands could impact quality control, increase costs, and ultimately delay the project.

A phased approach to localization appears to be the most likely solution. Initial production phases could prioritize components readily produced in India, while more complex systems would continue to be imported. Over the aircraft's service life, Indian industry could gradually assume responsibility for components requiring frequent upgrades or replacements.

Airframe manufacturing and other structural components, which are not frequently replaced, might see limited localization initially. The focus could instead be on components with shorter replacement cycles and higher maintenance demands, providing sustained opportunities for local industries.

To achieve long-term localization goals, the MoD and selected OEMs will need to invest in building a robust domestic supply chain. This involves technology transfers, skill development, and establishing high-quality manufacturing facilities. By gradually increasing localization, India can utilize the initial years of the MRFA project to develop a network of local suppliers capable of handling increasingly complex components over time.
 
20 production rate is also good if they can't go for 24. Because starting a new assembly line will take time, at least 4 years. OEM will also get the opportunity of exporting the fighter jets after meeting the IAF needs. It's a win-win opportunity for the MRFA winner. So starting with 30/40% localization is not justifying. Don't want imported components to be integrated, it should be manufactured by local vendors. Under MRFA, the ecosystem should be developed and the fighter jet should be built around it. Only who meets 70% localization will be the winner. OEMs do dilly-dally as competition hots up, it will put pressure on all contenders to start a local assembly line with the highest localization, just like it is happening in the submarine project. Both German & Spanish are offering over 60% ToT & localization.
 
Forget about MRFA for sure as -

Dassault consistently refused any local productions with TOTs. They only want to use near jail ready Anil Ambani Dabba factory to screwdrive and weld and close the shop as soon as the numbers completed. And then do forever MRO on Rafales.

IAF does not want any USA fighters.

IAF does not want Gripens at all.

So order 36 to 54 additional Rafales and make do with them by dispersing them along North and West.
And accelerate developments and productions of Tejas IAs, Tejas Mk IIs, TEDBFs, and AMCA Mk Is.

Invest massively in universities, labs, private and public, and even startups to realize Kaveri derivatives to man Indian fighters.
This is the only way forward.
 
Maybe something like this...
Initial 40-50 supplied with 40% localization
Rest Made in India with 70% localization
This ensures fastest delivery and time for domestic lines to mature.
 
Great decision by GOI and MOD. This will setup our own " ECOSYSTEM" for present and future fighters. I hope final deal will be signed by 2027 and production begins from 2030 onwards. This deal is much needed to maintain our squadron strength assuming we get MK1A and some MK2 by 2030.
 
BUY fighterjet through G2G route and set up critical spare parts plants in India with 100% TOT ! It will be cheaper option !
 
Again the MoD can consider and make several ideal plans that suit them but ultimately it will depend on the OEM on how much technology they want to give, what equipment and ToT they give, how much it will cost and what and how much local manufacturing they will allow. The truth is that the MRFA isn’t going to happen at all because it’s too expensive and the west are very reluctant on giving any technology transfer on critical technology and equipment like radars, jet computer and software, EW, engines, self protection pods etc. Usually they will only give away things that are not critical or difficult to manufacture like fuselage, wiring, pipes, components, screens, parts etc. On top of that you have to still heavily rely on the OEM for expensive spares, parts, servicing, maintenance, LRU, upgrades and weapons for the next 40 years or more.

India must focus solely on our indigenous programs. We need to fix the problems and delays to manufacture the Tejas MK1A. We need to quickly finish developing the Tejas MK2 and AMCA and start manufacturing the prototypes as they are ready so tests can begin right away.

Also instead of ordering another 97 Tejas MK1A jets they should order and manufacture more Tejas MK2 jets as they have better capabilities and can carry more weapons. In a large scale war with missiles flying everywhere in large quantities then only Tejas MK2 is capable of putting up a strong defence and if we attack then it will manage to strike more targets on one sortie. In either case it’s absolutely essential that we develop double or triple pylon on each hard point so it can increase the amount of missiles and bombs it can carry.
 
I think cancel MRFA. Order 72-90 su-30 with new engine and all super Sukhoi upgrade. Also some upgrade in body by using more composite on body Structure. These planes can started to come with in 2 years but any other than that will not come before 2030. We can't wait that long. So it is the best solution
 
Only 3,Companies have promised to deliver 24-25 jets/Year. Lockheed Martin/ Euro Fighter Consortium and SAAB.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
3,259
Messages
32,909
Members
1,989
Latest member
villagetalkies
Back
Top