India Needs 100,000 Shahed-Like Kamikaze Drones and Mass-Produced Interceptors for Modern Defence, Says Retd Lt Gen

India Needs 100,000 Shahed-Like Kamikaze Drones and Mass-Produced Interceptors for Modern Defence, Says Retd Lt Gen


Retired Lieutenant General Raj Shukla, an experienced former Indian Army commander and noted military strategist, has strongly advocated for India to rapidly accumulate inexpensive, long-range strike drones similar to Iran's Shahed models.

Speaking in episode 398 of the ANI podcast with Smita Prakash, titled "Iran War: 10 Lessons India Must Learn Now," he underscored the necessity of preparing for the shifting dynamics of modern warfare.

He noted that recent global clashes, particularly those in the Middle East, have highlighted how large fleets of low-cost drones can drastically disrupt traditional military operations.

Platforms like the Iranian Shahed-136 have redefined asymmetric warfare by offering immense destructive power at a fraction of the cost of conventional weapons.

Priced at roughly $35,000, these kamikaze drones feature robust warheads, simple piston engines built from commercially available parts, and ranges that extend well over 1,000 kilometres.

This creates a severe financial burden for the defending force. Taking down a single inexpensive drone frequently demands multimillion-dollar interceptor missiles from sophisticated surface-to-air systems, making mass "swarm" attacks incredibly difficult and costly to stop.

Viewing this cost imbalance as an urgent warning, Lt Gen Shukla advised that India needs to integrate at least 100,000 such kamikaze drones into its offensive arsenal.

He estimated that rapidly manufacturing this massive drone fleet would cost around ₹33,000 crore, urging that this target be met by March 2027 to ensure strong deterrence.

Fortunately, domestic initiatives are already stepping up to this challenge.

For example, Bengaluru-based NewSpace Research and Technologies recently unveiled the "Sheshnaag-150," an AI-driven swarm drone with a 1,000-kilometre range and a 40-kilogram payload capacity.

Similarly, Noida-based IG Defence is advancing "Project KAL," another long-range loitering munition designed for deep-penetration strikes.

Alongside offensive drones, Shukla stressed the absolute necessity of building cost-effective interceptors to defend against similar swarm attacks.

If India lacks affordable, mass-produced defensive measures, enemy drone swarms could rapidly exhaust the nation's expensive air defence missiles. To address this exact vulnerability, Indian private firms are already innovating.

Nagpur-based Solar Group recently tested "Bhargavastra," a first-of-its-kind guided micro-missile system designed specifically to counter drone swarms by firing 64 missiles in a single salvo, offering a much cheaper alternative to traditional high-end missiles.

These strategic recommendations reflect a growing demand to modernise India's military approach for a multipolar era.

Lt Gen Shukla has consistently criticised the slow bureaucratic processes and the "L1 disease"—the heavy reliance on selecting the lowest bidder—that stifle national security innovation.

He has also pointed out that an allocation of just 1.98% of the GDP to defence is insufficient for a rapidly developing nation.

Instead, he envisions a highly integrated "drone-rocket force" that merges unmanned aerial systems with precision artillery, heavily incorporating artificial intelligence and autonomous technology.

The Indian private sector is already moving rapidly to turn this vision into reality.

Companies like Solar Industries have heavily invested in scaled manufacturing, recently inaugurating a dedicated drone-making facility in Maharashtra capable of producing 1,000 loitering munitions annually, with plans to invest ₹10,000 crore over the next decade. Their "Nagastra-1" suicide drones have already been delivered to the Indian Army.

With startups also pushing boundaries in GPS-independent navigation and AI, India clearly possesses the industrial foundation required to build this massive drone force, provided that government policies and military requirements are aligned without delay.
 
Just do it discreetly don't publicise it to the entire world. Keep your weapons systems production within the walls of secrecy. But important point here's is walk the talk not just hot air. It is very common practice taking too much time to make things happen or in most cases it drags on for ages eventually nothing happens. Indian bureaucrats, MoD officials, the Armed forces top brass by now should have learned their lessons from past war experiences with the chinese buggers and the pakis. Now with the on going middle east war these people in high office should be even more knowledge of next-gen conflicts. Don't just talk just do it but keep your tricks in your inventory build up.
 
I don't agree entirely with Lt. Gen. Raj Shukla. I agree that country should have large number of interceptors for Kamikaze drones and other fast moving projectiles. But there is no need to have very large number of Kamikaze drones. Kamikaze drones are required for asymmetric warfare. Big powers like India can overwhelm enemy defences with many available means like it did during Operation Sindoor. And after wards can hit enemy high value targets with impunity.
 
The tactical shift you've identified is precisely what global military analysts are currently calling the "War of Numbers." The cost disparity between offensive drones and defensive interceptors has become a primary strategic challenge.

1. The Iran-Israel Cost Imbalance
The conflict in April 2024 (and subsequent escalations) proved your point about the "economic attrition" of modern warfare:

The Drone: Iran’s Shahed-136 costs between $20,000 and $50,000.

The Interceptor: Israel and the US used Arrow-3, David’s Sling, and Patriot (PAC-3) missiles. A single Patriot interceptor costs roughly $4 million, while an Arrow missile can cost over $3.5 million.

The Math: For every $1 Iran spent on an attack, Israel and its allies spent approximately $10 to $15 on defense. In one night of heavy barrages, Israel reportedly spent over $1 billion to neutralize a threat that cost Iran less than $100 million.

Regarding the USS Abraham Lincoln, while Iran claimed its missiles forced the carrier to retreat, the US Navy officially denied these reports, stating the carrier remained operational. However, the threat of swarm attacks is widely recognized as a "mission kill" risk—where even if a ship isn't sunk, damage to the flight deck can render a multi-billion dollar carrier useless.
+1

2. India's Urgent "Atmanirbhar" Drone Projects
India has fast-tracked several indigenous projects to address the exact range and cost requirements you mentioned:

Project Range / Capability Status
Sheshnaag-150 1,000 km+ range with 25–40 kg warhead. Inspired by the Shahed-136. Developed by NRT; first flight in early 2025.
Project KAL Long-range kamikaze/loitering munition. High-priority development by IG Defence.
Nagastra-1 Tactical loitering munition for precision strikes. Already being inducted/delivered to the Army.
Project Kusha India's "S-400 equivalent" for long-range air defense. Ground trials completed; flight tests expected in 2026.
3. The Low-Cost Interceptor: "YAMA"
To fight the "cost-effective war" you described, India is testing the YAMA Swarm Interceptor.

Cost: Approximately $10,000 per unit.

Advantage: This is 100 times cheaper than traditional missiles. It uses AI and autonomous swarm tactics to "hunt" enemy drones mid-air, preventing the exhaustion of expensive missile stockpiles.
+1

4. Strategic Integration
The Indian military is currently raising specialized drone platoons (like the Ashin and Bhairav units) across all three services. The goal is to move from "platform-centric" warfare (expensive jets/tanks) to "network-centric" warfare (thousands of low-cost, smart drones).

The government also recently slashed the GST on drone components from 18% to 5% to accelerate this domestic manufacturing ecosystem.

Would you like me to draft a summary of the technical specifications for the Sheshnaag-150 or the YAMA system for your records?

You said
You write total a post what is current situation and what India should do.

Gemini said
This analysis captures the critical crossroads India faces in 2026. The shift from "expensive missiles" to "mass-produced drones" is no longer a choice—it is a survival requirement for modern warfare.

Current Strategic Situation (March 2026)
The lessons from the 2024-2025 Iran-Israel clashes and the Ukraine conflict have fundamentally broken the old "Air Defense" model.

The Cost Trap: The world saw Iranian drones costing $20,000 forcing Israel/USA to fire interceptors costing $2 million to $4 million. This is a war of economic attrition. No nation, including India, can sustain a 1:100 cost ratio for long.

Carrier Vulnerability: As seen with recent threats to high-value assets like the USS Abraham Lincoln, large platforms (Carriers, Destroyers, Airbases) are now vulnerable to "death by a thousand cuts" from small, low-cost "suicide" drones.

India’s Response: In 2025-26, India successfully executed "Operation Sindoor," using indigenous loitering munitions for precision surgical strikes. This proved that our domestic tech works, but we still lack the mass needed for a full-scale conflict.

What India Must Do: A 4-Point Strategic Roadmap
1. Rapid Mass-Production of "Shahed-Class" Drones
India needs an arsenal of 10,000+ "disposable" long-range drones to saturate enemy defenses.

Sheshnaag-150 & Project KAL: These indigenous drones (with 1,000 km+ range) must be produced at a scale of hundreds per month.

The "Magnum" Standard: We must standardize a 25–40 kg warhead (Magnum class) across these platforms to ensure they can destroy hardened targets like radar hubs and fuel depots, not just "soft" targets.

Indigenous Navigation: Dependence on foreign GPS is a risk. All drones must be hard-coded with NavIC and Visual AI-based navigation to operate in "GPS-denied" environments where signals are jammed.

2. Deploy "YAMA" Class Low-Cost Interceptors
We cannot keep using Akash or S-400 missiles to shoot down $10,000 drones.

The $10k Solution: India’s new YAMA Swarm Interceptor (costing roughly $10,000) is the correct path. These "drone-killers" must be deployed at every border outpost.

Kinetic & Electronic Grids: We need a "Counter-Drone Grid" that combines electronic jamming with "hard-kill" interceptor drones to win the cost-ratio battle.

3. Radical Integration (The "Shaurya Squadron" Model)
Drones shouldn't just be with the Air Force; they must be "standard equipment" for every soldier.

Army: Embed Shaurya Squadrons (dedicated drone units) into every Tank Regiment and Infantry Battalion. Every Major and Colonel should have their own "eyes in the sky" and "precision hammers."

Navy: Every Frigate and Destroyer must carry a swarm of 50+ loitering munitions to counter incoming anti-ship missiles or enemy swarms.

Air Force: Shift from "manned-only" to "Manned-Unmanned Teaming" (MUM-T), where one Tejas jet controls five "loyal wingman" drones.

4. Policy & Ecosystem Overhaul
Supply Chain Sovereignty: We still rely on foreign chips and sensors. India must treat Drone Semiconductors as a strategic priority equivalent to nuclear energy.

Emergency Procurement: The current "Emergency Revenue Procurement" used by the Army to buy 1,000 drones should be made the standard for the next 5 years to bypass bureaucratic delays.

The Verdict: To fight a cost-effective war, India must stop thinking of drones as "hi-tech toys" and start treating them like "flying bullets." We need quantity, we need NavIC-based autonomy, and we need a defense that costs less than the attack.
 
Yes but with little longer range. Range should be atleast 1500 km to keep enemy at Bay. Their Aircraft should be kept at such a distance that enemy planes should not take off from AC, reach Indian sold and reach back to AC to land with internal fuel.
 
Its shameful that nation like Bharat 4th largest economy of the world, spending U$80billion a year on defence and billions on IITs, world class engineering firms and ecosystem with millions of young engineers but LOOKING UPTO failed nation like Iran with poor industrial base and less spending.
Iran showing the light to Bharat for Drones!! such a shameful day for Bharat!!
 

Forum statistics

Threads
6,747
Messages
64,249
Members
5,140
Latest member
mayarawat
Back
Top