Unveiling HAL’s Significant Design Contributions to the AMCA Project Despite the Shift Toward Private Sector Prototypes

Unveiling HAL’s Significant Design Contributions to the AMCA Project Despite the Shift Toward Private Sector Prototypes


The Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA)—India’s ambitious stride into the realm of fifth-generation stealth fighters—has recently dominated defence headlines.

Much of the discourse has focused on reports that Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL) has been excluded from the initial prototype and development phase.

Instead, major private conglomerates such as Tata Advanced Systems, Larsen & Toubro (L&T), and Bharat Forge have emerged as the frontrunners to partner with the Aeronautical Development Agency (ADA).

While this marks a historic pivot away from HAL’s traditional monopoly over fighter production, a crucial aspect of the narrative remains largely overlooked: HAL has already embedded a significant portion of its engineering DNA into the AMCA’s design.

Although the ADA, operating under the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO), serves as the primary architect for the AMCA’s core stealth geometry and aerodynamics, HAL has been far more than a silent spectator.

Senior leadership at the state-owned enterprise, including Chairman and Managing Director D.K. Sunil, has revealed that HAL is responsible for approximately 20-25% of the aircraft’s overall design work.

This contribution is not merely theoretical; it leverages the practical, hard-won expertise HAL has gained from decades of managing the Tejas Light Combat Aircraft (LCA) and the Dhruv helicopter programmes.

HAL’s engineering footprint is visible in some of the most critical subsystems of the stealth fighter. The organisation has collaborated closely with ADA on the stealth-optimised airframe, utilising advanced carbon composites and radar-absorbing materials essential for reducing the aircraft's visibility to enemy sensors.

Furthermore, HAL has played a pivotal role in designing the avionics suite, including the mission computers, cockpit displays, and electronic warfare systems, adapting proven technologies from the Tejas Mk1A upgrades.

The company has also been involved in the fabrication of complex structural elements, such as the leading-edge sections, which require specialised manufacturing techniques to meet fifth-generation standards.

The government’s decision to look beyond HAL for the prototype phase is driven by logistical pragmatism rather than a lack of confidence in the PSU’s technical abilities.

The primary factor is HAL’s massive order book, which currently stands at nearly eight times its annual revenue—far exceeding the "3x revenue" limit set by the selection committee for the AMCA prototype bid.

With urgent commitments to deliver over 180 Tejas Mk1A jets, accelerate the LCA Mk2, manufacture Prachand combat helicopters, and assemble GE F414 engines, HAL’s production lines are operating at maximum capacity.

Bringing in private players is a strategic move to ensure the AMCA project adheres to strict timelines, aiming for a prototype rollout around 2028-29 without overburdening the existing aerospace infrastructure.

Ultimately, this shift represents an expansion of India’s aerospace capabilities rather than a replacement of HAL.

While private firms may construct the initial prototypes to prove the concept, HAL has indicated it will aggressively bid for the mass production contracts anticipated in the mid-2030s. At that stage, its unparalleled infrastructure for scaling up fighter manufacturing will be indispensable.

The emerging model for the AMCA project—combining ADA’s design leadership, HAL’s subsystem expertise, and the private sector’s agility—signals the maturation of a true national defence ecosystem under the vision of Aatmanirbhar Bharat.
 
That's need. We will have to trust the private sector. HAL should focus on Tejas Mk1 and Mk2, it is good for them.
 
Beautifully writing. But whrlere is engine? Why not able build engine by hal and drdo. Why dragging safran for engine development? Just wroting article not enough. Actually avonics developed by drdo by project vetrivel for su30 mki.
 
That's need. We will have to trust the private sector. HAL should focus on Tejas Mk1 and Mk2, it is good for them.
"Ultimately, this shift represents an expansion of India’s aerospace capabilities rather than a replacement of HAL."

HAL has the technical skill set. The goal is to involve the private sector in the ecosystem. The private companies do not have the skill set to take over. This would set India back 10 years. Plus, the private sector operates on profit. Profit is quantifiable on components and airframes. Not taking on a black hole.

HAL needs to change the culture that holds back all state enterprises. Things like advancement just because of seniority and not based on excellence. That;s why Indian SOE's don't work. Plus the babus in government have too much control. HAL was sent out 5 years ago by the government to sell the Tejas when we couldn't even produce enough for India. Plus, it has no weapons, just like the 1A. Who would buy it? Delusional!
 
Beautifully writing. But whrlere is engine? Why not able build engine by hal and drdo. Why dragging safran for engine development? Just wroting article not enough. Actually avonics developed by drdo by project vetrivel for su30 mki.
Countries that make world class engines have private companies that spent 50 years to learn and perfect their craft. This included, design, manufacturing, metallurgy etc. This took massive investment over many decades. GE probably spent $50 billion in today's money to do this and the government had the stomach to fund this.

India had to go through this process. It is wise to work with countries that have already gone through this. The strategy India is employing is correct. Indian funding was on again and off again. Every time we lost our best and brightest to the west and had to start over.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
6,336
Messages
62,758
Members
4,946
Latest member
Mhora
Back
Top