US Hesitant to Share Full F414 Engine Tech with India Due to Close Defence Ties with Russia: Financial Times

tejas-mk2-with-f414-engine-webp.788


India is poised to enter the elite club of nations capable of manufacturing indigenous fighter jet engines, a significant advancement for its defence industry. Currently, this complex technology is mastered only by the permanent members of the UN Security Council: China, France, Russia, the UK, and the US.

As India seeks to develop a cutting-edge engine for its next-generation fighter jets, it is fielding offers from several global defence giants, including France's Safran, the UK's Rolls-Royce, and the US's General Electric (GE).

While all three nations are eager to partner with India, the offer from GE comes with a caveat. According to a recent report by the Financial Times, the US is hesitant to share the complete intellectual property (IP) for its F414 engine due to concerns stemming from India's long-standing defence relationship with Russia.

Sources indicate that the US government is apprehensive about potential technology transfer to Russia, given the close ties between Moscow and New Delhi. This hesitation has led to a proposed co-development model where a small portion of the IP would be withheld.

Despite this limitation, some analysts believe that the US proposal remains a strong contender. Amit Cowshish, a former senior official in India's Ministry of Defence, suggests that Washington's global influence and established defence relations with India could give their offer significant weight.

"The Americans could possibly be pushing harder with the kind of clout they have, which is much more than that of any other country," Cowshish stated, emphasizing the strategic partnership between the two nations.

However, Safran and Rolls-Royce have presented competing offers that include full transfer of IP rights to India. These proposals would grant India complete control over the technology, including the right to export co-developed engines.

Safran's chairman, Ross McInnes, publicly addressed India's Defence Conclave earlier this month, assuring them of Safran's commitment and contrasting their offer of full IP transfer with that of "other western partners," in an apparent jab at the US.

Rolls-Royce has also expressed a strong interest in collaborating with Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL), India's state-owned aerospace company, to develop a customized engine for India's Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA) program. This fifth-generation fighter jet is a key component of India's pursuit of self-reliance in defence technology.

The competition to secure this partnership with India highlights the country's growing importance in the global defence market. India's ambitious military modernization plans aim to bolster its defence manufacturing capabilities through strategic collaborations with leading aerospace companies.

For India, the decision goes beyond immediate technological gains. It involves a complex evaluation of long-term strategic partnerships, defence autonomy, and the desire to reduce reliance on foreign imports, all while ensuring control over any co-developed technology.

The outcome of this decision holds significant implications for India's defence landscape. Joining the ranks of fighter jet engine manufacturers would further solidify India's position as a rising global power in defence technology.
 
Our Govt should not even discuss with GE if they want to retain slittle of intellectual property that may be similar to the pituitary gland. What is the use of body without that gland
 
China holds all Russian technology. Likewise we should go for Russian TOT. Then only these US UK people will learn a lesson. Delaying tactics is the main aim of US and UK.
 
A-least UK gave us so much freedom in Jaguar, Hawker Siddeley, Harrier jump jet and many engines in the past, we could able to upgrade ourself free of cost as they gave us access to the source code, we didn’t pay $60Mln to upgrade each jet every time, now US is giving 80% TOT on GE-F414, what did France give except charging $300bln for Rafale, useless $60Mln upgrade for each Mirage, not meeting a single offset obligation.
All indian helicopters are powered by french engines. ISRO's PSLV/GSLV vikas rocket engines has it roots from french viking engines. No body will give their IP for money regardless how much you pay....we have to develope our own IP. That's why France is now ready for a joint R&D with India albeit for a charge for what they bring to the table.
 
India should've been aware of this much ahead. I'm 200% sure India must be knowing this fact well in advance.

THEN, WHY INDIA IS GOING AFTER GE ??? WHY ? WHY ?? WHY ???

There was another article in another defense portal that India pathetically missed (rather miserably failed) in getting the jet engine technology from Russia. It stated that Russia's engine is superior in almost every aspect, but still India didn't pursue that option of either TOT or co-production like Brahmos. Had it been done, India would've got its own (though can't be called 100% indigenous, but hey, same is going to be the case with F414 as well, isn't it ?) engine by now, powering ALL Tejas variants.

Russia would've readily accepted as it's a win-win for both.

Moreover, Rolls Royce and Safran offer 100% TOT. Esp. I sense that France is DO AGGRESSIVE to become India's primary defense partner/ supplier to get the lion's share of the HUGE Indian defense market, replacing Russia and hence it offered completely NSA deal for the engine technology (like IP rights, selling rights etc will ALL be with India and France won't care)

Why can't India grab it with both the hands ?

Is the US still dictating terms and India still budging ???
 

Forum statistics

Threads
3,098
Messages
29,279
Members
1,677
Latest member
SIDD
Back
Top