Despite Pakistan's 5th-Gen Fighter Acquisition, India Must Prioritize Indigenous AMCA over Stopgap Foreign Import, Asserts Ex-IAF Chief

Despite Pakistan's 5th-Gen Fighter Acquisition, India Must Prioritize Indigenous AMCA over Stopgap Foreign Import, Asserts Ex-IAF Chief


Former Indian Air Force (IAF) Chief, Air Chief Marshal (Retd) RKS Bhadauria, has strongly advised against India importing fifth-generation fighter aircraft as a stopgap measure, even as reports suggest Pakistan may acquire advanced stealth fighters from China.

Instead, he emphasized the critical need for a focused national effort to accelerate the development and induction of India's own Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA), a fifth-generation fighter program.

Responding to queries about India potentially looking at foreign fifth-generation jets due to Pakistan's likely procurement of stealth aircraft like China's J-20 or FC-31/J-35, Bhadauria firmly stated, "My answer is no."

He added, "The government has clearly put their faith in AMCA, and now we need to do everything as a nation to expedite the AMCA."

The AMCA is being designed as a state-of-the-art multirole combat aircraft with advanced stealth features, supercruise capability, and sophisticated avionics.

The retired Air Chief Marshal, instrumental in shaping the IAF's modernisation roadmap during his service, acknowledged that Pakistan potentially operating stealth aircraft before India is a concern.

However, he asserted that this situation should not lead India to abandon its indigenous development path. He advocated for strengthening India’s countermeasures and interim defensive capabilities to manage any new threats effectively.

"That cause of concern in terms of what Pakistan is going to get from China in the interim—be it J-20 or J-35—let them get these. That will be studied," Bhadauria remarked.

He stressed the importance of India’s interim strategies, stating, "What is important is in the interim how do you handle these threats, and there are ways and means of tackling this threat that they will have."

While Pakistan might gain a temporary edge in stealth technology, the former IAF chief highlighted that India possesses multiple options to counter such capabilities without derailing its long-term objective of achieving self-reliance in defence production.

Fifth-generation fighter aircraft are typically characterized by their stealth (low observability to radar), high manoeuvrability, advanced sensors, and networked operational capabilities.

Explaining the interim defensive strategy, Bhadauria said, "In terms of stealth capability, Pakistan is likely to get it before us. We’ll have to take some other measures in order to be able to detect by some means, to be able to still hold them off our borders much inside so that they are unable to launch."

He further assured that India would be capable of "tackling the weapons" should adversaries manage to launch cruise missiles or other standoff armaments.

His comments underscore a broader strategic vision for India: instead of making hasty foreign purchases in reaction to Pakistan’s moves, India should concentrate on enhancing its own defence network.

This includes investing in counter-stealth technologies like over-the-horizon radars and multi-static radar systems, alongside relying on superior operational tactics and integrated command and control structures.

Air Chief Marshal (Retd) Bhadauria’s resolute position aligns with the Indian government's "Atmanirbhar Bharat" (self-reliant India) initiative. It also signifies strong institutional backing for the indigenous AMCA program, which is anticipated to see its first prototype roll out later this decade.

With substantial investment and collaborative efforts already in progress, the AMCA is considered the cornerstone of India's future air power and its ambitions for a domestically developed fifth-generation fighter fleet.
 
Wise words from the former air chief. Double down on AMCA, Tejas Mk. 2. Perhaps also urgently acquire aerial refuellers and order more Netra 1A and Netra 2 AEWCS (not just the 6 more Mk 1As and 6 of Mk 2s approved, but more).
 
This is a very bad idea. Our AMCA will not be a reality before 2040. If IAF waits for so long, then it will be a huge blunder. Buy F-35 now. F-35 will give India a huge advantage over China and Pakistan. IAF should buy 3-4 squadrons of F-35 along with some additional Rafales.
 
This is a very bad idea. Our AMCA will not be a reality before 2040. If IAF waits for so long, then it will be a huge blunder. Buy F-35 now. F-35 will give India a huge advantage over China and Pakistan. IAF should buy 3-4 squadrons of F-35 along with some additional Rafales.
Nope. F-35 comes under many USA conditions. Best alternative: buy six squadrons of Su-57, at least, under Make in India, equipped with Virupaksha radars, BrahMos-NG, Astra Mk3, and R-37 missiles.
 
AMCA takes time, minimum 10 to 15 years. We are surrounded from three sides. Pakistan and Bangladesh get 5th Gen fighter from China. We need to act first. Urgently produce Su-57 under Make in India with indigenous parts, avionics, radar, weapons, missiles. AMCA can continue, first track 110kN Engine with Safran of France or GE of USA.
 
A lot of people here be like, "Buy F-35," don't even know that the F-35 is not suitable for India in the first place. Since India has a lot of French and Russian equipment and now indigenous equipment, the F-35 will be a disaster for us, as it requires regular software updates to integrate and to identify friend and foe. In turn, all this data is sent back to the US, so it will be like handing over our indigenous hardware to the US on a silver platter. Just remember, we surprised the world in a recent war with Pak just because we had our indigenous hardware and systems along with phoren maal.
 
The first prototype must come within three years from now. HAL should fast-track the entire process and develop a full-scale model by 2028. From 2030, induction should start. This is quite achievable if we work in a mission mode under PPP.
 
Very wise words from Bhadauria sir. Only indigenous products work in the long term. It also increases self-reliance. Only having fifth-gen jets doesn't do magic. There are a lot of things that will be done on the battlefield. Now involve private firms and academia along with DRDO and other required organisations for accelerating AMCA. It should be done on a wartime basis.
 
Why not cancelling the MRFA and giving production licenses to the private sector for Tejas MK-II, aiming to start multiple production lines simultaneously, which could reduce the production-to-procurement timeline significantly?
 
Yes that's the way to go. Kaveri gtx-35vs is quite capable 5th gen engine with 1750K temperature sustainability with advanced materials we can bring the weight down and power up. Don't forget it's a flat rated engine delivering stable power curve in Indian subcontinent condition apart from other engines. After this is tested in ghatak and Tejas trainers flights we can develop this in the next 2 yrs to reach 2250K we should invest in testing facilities and advanced materials research labs in all the premier metallurgy institutes in India and work on advanced materials with the help of academia, poach Indians from abroad to work on this program. Don't invest in importing 6th gen, it's a system of systems only need to be developed indigenous and integrate with our Akash Teer and our satellites , no one can touch us in our Subcontinent anyway we are peaceful and don't need to project power across the globe, it's only our backyard we need to cover and no one will be better than us in that
 

Forum statistics

Threads
5,238
Messages
52,455
Members
3,411
Latest member
Yedwise
Back
Top