MoD May Consider Russian Su-57E For IAF's Immediate 5th-Gen Needs, Local Production and Full Source Code Access Key Factors

MoD May Consider Russian Su-57E For IAF's Immediate 5th-Gen Needs, Local Production and Full Source Code Access Key Factors


India's Ministry of Defence is evaluating a renewed proposal from Russia to supply its Su-57E fifth-generation stealth fighter, as the Indian Air Force (IAF) seeks to address a critical shortfall in its combat fleet.

The offer is reportedly being considered as a potential stop-gap measure to modernise India's aerial capabilities while its indigenous advanced combat aircraft program continues development.

Russia's comprehensive offer includes options for both a direct off-the-shelf purchase and, more significantly, licensed production in India.

The proposal suggests manufacturing the advanced jets at Hindustan Aeronautics Limited's (HAL) facility in Nashik. This plant has extensive experience, having produced over 220 Su-30MKI fighters, making it a prime candidate for such a high-tech undertaking.

A key highlight of the deal is the offer of full access to the aircraft's source code, a crucial element that would allow India to integrate its own arsenal of weapons, such as the Astra and Brahmos missiles, and upgrade the jet's systems independently.

The Ministry of Defence, in collaboration with the IAF, is expected to spend the next several weeks carefully assessing the proposal.

The evaluation comes as the IAF grapples with a combat fleet reduced to approximately 31 squadrons, significantly below the sanctioned strength of 42 required to manage potential two-front threats.

This urgency is compounded by regional developments, including China's progress with its own stealth fighters like the J-35A. Reports suggest India could be looking to procure between 40 and 60 Su-57E jets to counter these emerging challenges.

A notable feature of the latest Russian proposal is the offer to configure the Su-57E to be compatible with systems being developed for the IAF's Su-30MKI fleet upgrade. This would streamline logistics, maintenance, and pilot training, creating valuable synergy between the two platforms.

The focus on local manufacturing at the HAL Nashik plant also strongly aligns with the government's "Make in India" and "Atmanirbhar Bharat" (self-reliant India) initiatives, promoting domestic defence production.

The Su-57E is Russia's export version of its premier fifth-generation multirole fighter, designed for air superiority and attack missions.

Its primary features include stealth technology to reduce radar visibility, supermaneuverability for advanced combat agility, and the ability to cruise at supersonic speeds without using afterburners.

While the aircraft is currently powered by the AL-41F1 engine, it is slated to receive the more powerful and efficient 'Izdeliye 30' engine in the future.

This is not the first time India has considered the Su-57 platform. A previous collaboration with Russia, known as the Fifth Generation Fighter Aircraft (FGFA) program, was shelved in 2018.

The decision was made due to concerns over high development costs, disagreements on work-share, and questions regarding the aircraft's engine reliability and stealth capabilities at the time.

However, the pressing need to bridge a looming air power gap before India's own Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA) becomes operational—expected around 2035—has brought the Russian offer back into consideration.

Should the deal proceed, the Su-57E would become the first fifth-generation fighter to be inducted into the Indian Air Force. This acquisition could provide a significant technological advantage and enhance India's deterrent posture in an increasingly complex security environment, securing the nation's airspace for the coming decade.
 
No point on assessment without concrete fast-track decision making. Have been hearing about this deal from past few months and years with no solution and decision neither from IAF nor from GOI. At present there is no better option than SU57 for depleting Air power that India is facing. Our AMCA is just in the middle of discussion and the real work might start in near future. AMCA engine finalization will take another minimum six to seven months as the declaration will be done somewhere by end of this year which is too long. F35 will be death order by America for IAF so no chance of F35 with all the tantrums it comes with. You wont be getting J35 from China its out of window. What remains is only SU57 and it is a very formidable machine which comes with all the requirements that India wants. This ToT will be as good as India 5th gen jet. This will help Indian brains to work with 5th gen technology and apply the positives to AMCA project and how to improve the shortfalls. I think instead of pondering over the deal fast forward the deal as even if we opt for 40 jets off the shelf it will definitely take a year or two to complete the task and we are loosing the time which India critically do not have with them. The reason being the disaster that GE has forced on India and the Tejas project in real jeopardy. With Trump getting closer to pakistan there will be no improvement in the near future as seen.
 
Russia must upgrade Su-57 RCS at par with F-35 if they want joint production with India !
F35 is a hyped machine, recently we have seen the negative side of F35 previously it was told that due to insufficient fuel RAF had to land F35 in Kerala. Still the F35 is on the ground about one week past this due to the hydraulics issues which remains unsettled. Even the Pentagon has slashed to orders due to technical complications they have faced with the machine. So overall the F35 is more hyped than a true stealth and if the Iran claims are true if they really are of targeting and destroying about 3 to 4 jets then that is the big big blow to the claims of this being the best in business.
 
No point on assessment without concrete fast-track decision making. Have been hearing about this deal from past few months and years with no solution and decision neither from IAF nor from GOI. At present there is no better option than SU57 for depleting Air power that India is facing. Our AMCA is just in the middle of discussion and the real work might start in near future. AMCA engine finalization will take another minimum six to seven months as the declaration will be done somewhere by end of this year which is too long. F35 will be death order by America for IAF so no chance of F35 with all the tantrums it comes with. You wont be getting J35 from China its out of window. What remains is only SU57 and it is a very formidable machine which comes with all the requirements that India wants. This ToT will be as good as India 5th gen jet. This will help Indian brains to work with 5th gen technology and apply the positives to AMCA project and how to improve the shortfalls. I think instead of pondering over the deal fast forward the deal as even if we opt for 40 jets off the shelf it will definitely take a year or two to complete the task and we are loosing the time which India critically do not have with them. The reason being the disaster that GE has forced on India and the Tejas project in real jeopardy. With Trump getting closer to pakistan there will be no improvement in the near future as seen.

SU57 is using lots of Chinese equipment. Thatll b a headache.
That thing has to be taken care of before any deal is finalised. Insist on Russian components replacement. But India has to move very fast killing Babu's red tapism and coming out of self patting mode after operation sindur. Pakistan is only wounded and will retaliate surely after some time. So wakeup IAF, Indian Government and Indian Babus. HAL has to be kicked out of its deep sleep and put into some real work. Search replacement engines for GE404 and 414. Forget about commissions.
 
That thing has to be taken care of before any deal is finalised. Insist on Russian components replacement. But India has to move very fast killing Babu's red tapism and coming out of self patting mode after operation sindur. Pakistan is only wounded and will retaliate surely after some time. So wakeup IAF, Indian Government and Indian Babus. HAL has to be kicked out of its deep sleep and put into some real work. Search replacement engines for GE404 and 414. Forget about commissions.
Absolutely agree with this, they are wounded and will try to retaliate so we need to be prepared which we definitely are which is shown by continuous drills and air exercises. The interdependency of Russia and China is well balanced so China wont play plot for parts of SU57. Though the Chinese angle is there in SU 57 this should not be hinderance for deal of SU57 as no county is completely independent or self sufficient in itself.
 
It's a great offer for IAF to induction the SU57 with full TOT and source code. It's an excellent platform as far as range , weapon payload, speed and Agility is concerned. India can collaborate with Russia to improve stealth and integrate cutting edge avionics and weapons like GAN AESA radar, Brahmos NG , Astra MK3, Rudram and Russian hypersonic missiles to make it a really potent air dominance platform. Constant delays in TejasMK1, MK2 and AMCA programs by HAL makes it important to go ahead with this deal and not widen the capability gaps with air force of histile neighbours
 
Russia must upgrade Su-57 RCS at par with F-35 if they want joint production with India !
It's average rcs is already similar to American 5th gen and better Rear aspect stealth with new engine, not to mention it's way way more stealthy than any 4th gen platform and better than f35 by miles if you compare both these jets objectively.
 
If considered, we need to get the private sector involved in a big way. Maybe tender it out to see who can manufacture it fastest/cheapest etc. In pursuit of profit, private sector will indigenize at max to reduce costs. HAL has no such motivation.
 
If Russia provide new engine which is still in trial stage with provisions to replace radar with our own, sharing code to integrate indian missiles then buying 36 SU57 is not a bad option with complete technology Transfer.
 
Yes Su57 along with Al51 engine and long-range missiles make in India and involve private companies to indigenise maximum spareparts.
Get source code to integrate indigenious radar avionics display systems armaments and missiles and EW systems.
 
Like we even have any other option with us.

If India goes with Su-57E purchase, the biggest question will be:

Why did India even leave the FGFA project? Are all issues resolved which India raised with Su-57? And if Su-57 is going to be chosen, then what about MRFA?

If India had stuck to the FGFA project, we might be operating at least one squad by now.

If IAF and MoD made their mind to stick to AMCA and not to import any other aircraft except MRFA, then stick to it only.
 
This is the right opportunity to grab the offer with the depleting squadron we have..not only that a 5th gen fighter with full source code is extremely good offer. Ita like a circuit board with its entire coding given into your hands..imagine what India can do with it. Our brains can in no time indegenise it. This is will be a mutual benefit for both India and Russia because of the fact export factor as India's products are geting the respect and value they desrve. Govt should move fast..for godsake don't keep this offer under someone butt for another 5 years...
 

Forum statistics

Threads
4,683
Messages
52,898
Members
3,562
Latest member
sky
Back
Top