Analysis How $40 Billion Rafale Deal Risks Overshadowing Tejas Mk2 and Disrupting India’s Indigenous Defence Roadmap

How $40 Billion Rafale Deal Risks Overshadowing Tejas Mk2 and Disrupting India’s Indigenous Defence Roadmap


The Indian Ministry of Defence is reportedly nearing a decision on a colossal ₹3.25 lakh crore (approximately $40 billion) procurement of 114 Rafale fighter jets.

While this potential contract is being heralded as a decisive solution to the Indian Air Force’s (IAF) dwindling squadron strength, defence analysts warn it may severely undercut the indigenous Tejas Mk2 programme, disrupting the nation's long-term industrial strategy.

The Indigenous "Bridge" Under Threat​

The Tejas Mk2 was conceptualised as the critical bridge in India's fighter development roadmap.

It was designed to replace the IAF's ageing medium-weight fleet—specifically the Mirage 2000, SEPECAT Jaguar, and MiG-29 squadrons.

Originally, the IAF projected a requirement for 180 to 200 of these indigenous jets to serve as the new backbone of its combat fleet.

However, the scale of the proposed Rafale acquisition threatens to dismantle these projections.

If the government proceeds with purchasing 114 Multi-Role Fighter Aircraft (MRFA) from France, the Tejas Mk2 order could be effectively capped at approximately 120 aircraft (six squadrons).

The massive financial outlay required for the Rafales would likely absorb the majority of the capital budget for the next decade, leaving little fiscal room for a large-scale indigenous medium fighter programme.

A Squeeze Between Two Giants​

The Tejas Mk2 now faces an existential "squeeze" from two directions: the immediate influx of foreign fighters and the future priority of next-generation indigenous platforms.
  1. The Rafale Dominance: With 36 Rafales already in service and 114 more potentially on the way, the IAF’s fleet would host nearly 150 of these French jets. This would make the Rafale, rather than the Tejas Mk2, the dominant medium-weight platform well into the 2040s.
  2. The AMCA Future: On the other end of the timeline lies the Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA), India’s indigenous fifth-generation stealth fighter. With its induction scheduled to begin around 2035, the AMCA will naturally command the bulk of future funding and strategic focus.
Caught in the middle, the Tejas Mk2 risks becoming a supplementary, limited-run aircraft rather than the primary workhorse it was intended to be.

Light Fighter Segment Secured; Medium Segment in Flux​

While the medium-weight category faces uncertainty, the light fighter segment remains secure.

The IAF has effectively locked in its plans for the next decade with firm orders for 83 Tejas Mk1A jets, and a follow-on contract for an additional 97 aircraft is expected shortly.

The disparity lies in the strategic vision for the heavier categories.

The Tejas Mk2 was meant to mature India’s aerospace ecosystem by scaling up the integration of the powerful GE-414 engines and anchoring domestic avionics development.

Shifting the center of gravity to a foreign platform like the Rafale could dilute these industrial gains.

Short-Term Fixes vs Long-Term Strategy​

Defence experts point out the irony in the Rafale’s expanding role.

The aircraft was initially introduced as an emergency "stopgap" measure comprising just 36 jets. It has since evolved into a potential fleet of 150, fundamentally reshaping the IAF’s force structure around imported hardware.

Recent reports from January 2026 suggest that operational pressures—exacerbated by delays in local manufacturing and urgent threat assessments—are driving this pivot.

While the Rafale is undoubtedly a potent machine, its selection in such large numbers raises uncomfortable questions about the consistency of India’s "Atmanirbhar Bharat" defence roadmap.

If the $40 billion deal concludes as currently envisioned, the Tejas Mk2 may pay the price—not due to a lack of technical capability, but because long-term indigenous vision was overtaken by immediate operational arithmetic.
 
Personal Opinion...I think we shouldn't take Rafale as a risk to our indigenous content, but rather as a short term booster till Tejas mk1a, Mk2 and AMCA are ready with decent numbers.

Main issue is budget, we need to bump the defence budget from 1.9% of GDP to atleast 2.5% of GDP, and this has to sustain till 2050, as along with IAF, even IA and IN need funds to complete their orders.
 
Waiting for final confirmation bcz gov also knows that the current opposition parties just want a topic to bark upon and they will not like them to give them a chance, but we have no other option other than to choose rafales
 
Think big as India is going to face Muslim NATO and China at same time in future so we need to have 75+ squadron IAF not mere sanctioned 30 odd older squadrons, Divert fund form inland Road infra plan to defence purchase and Make in India ! We Need Rafales, F-15EX-II/F-XX, Su-57 & F-35s , THAAD and S-500 ,PAC-III ,NASAMS,AKASH, Spyders, Aegis, Laser beam dome all to defend India no country specfic approach only need Indian Defence centric approach !
 
Think big as India is going to face Muslim NATO and China at same time in future so we need to have 75+ squadron IAF not mere sanctioned 30 odd older squadrons, Divert fund form inland Road infra plan to defence purchase and Make in India ! We Need Rafales, F-15EX-II/F-XX, Su-57 & F-35s , THAAD and S-500 ,PAC-III ,NASAMS,AKASH, Spyders, Aegis, Laser beam dome all to defend India no country specfic approach only need Indian Defence centric approach !
But the gov sees freebies, ladli behen as more important and more importantly the citizens just vote for 500,1000 rupees that's why they divert all money to these freebies which yields nothing to nation
 
Think big as India is going to face Muslim NATO and China at same time in future so we need to have 75+ squadron IAF not mere sanctioned 30 odd older squadrons, Divert fund form inland Road infra plan to defence purchase and Make in India ! We Need Rafales, F-15EX-II/F-XX, Su-57 & F-35s , THAAD and S-500 ,PAC-III ,NASAMS,AKASH, Spyders, Aegis, Laser beam dome all to defend India no country specfic approach only need Indian Defence centric approach !
All western F35, F15, Rafales are mediocre. Pls look at the SMO in Ukraine the entire west is pouring in hundreds of billions in weapons and equipment, aircrafts. Strangely none of the jets they want to sell to us, gibtonfscd thd Migs & Sukhois. The performance of Rafale is pathetic compared to our good old Su30. With its low ceiling, low payload, poor maneurability Rafale will be useless against China and Pakistan Himalayan region. F35 which which made emergency landing
Personal Opinion...I think we shouldn't take Rafale as a risk to our indigenous content, but rather as a short term booster till Tejas mk1a, Mk2 and AMCA are ready with decent numbers.

Main issue is budget, we need to bump the defence budget from 1.9% of GDP to atleast 2.5% of GDP, and this has to sustain till 2050, as along with IAF, even IA and IN need funds to complete their orders.
If at all we have to get foreign fighter jets it should be from Russia. Su57 is streets ahead of anything the west has to offer. Rafale vs not match our good old Su30 in performance. Top priority should be Tejas with Saturn engines not sloppy GE or Safran.
But the gov sees freebies, ladli behen as more important and more importantly the citizens just vote for 500,1000 rupees that's why they divert all money to these freebies which yields nothing to nation
Instead of super expensive toys like Rafale we should go in for Su57 and S500 and Migs. With full manufacturing in Bharat. Also Tejas 100% Bharatiya should be achieved engine tech should be from Saturn , Russian. Also our Russian aircraft and equipment tech should be kept safe from the spying west and we should use only Jaguar and Rafales for combined exercise with western colonial powers. Jai Hind.
 
We have to remember our war is against imperialism. China has not attacked us. Russia has not attacked us. USA along with its Middle East vassals, Pakistan, and ASEAN colonies are the ones encircling us. In fact, the greatest threat to an unified continental Europe and well as united India comes from the Anglo American Arab Triple threat. The largest stockpile of American fighter jets after mainland US is in Saudi, UAE, Qatar, Turkey taken together. Afghanistan, Yemen, Syria are the largest source of battle hardened light infantry. Turkey, Pakistan, Egypt have the pilots.

Today, the Russians are pushing west, thru ukraine. Fulcrum is the Crimea. 10 years from now, there is bound to be a similar push twds east. Where will the fulcrum be, then ?

INDIANS MUST ALWAYS ALWAYS BEWARE THE GREAT DECEPTION. THE REALIZATION THAT MILITARY ASSETS OF MIDDLE EASTERN COUNTRIES BETWEEN SUEZ AND KARACHI CAN BE MOBILIZED UNDER ONE BANNER IS FOUNDATIONAL TO OUR SENSE OF NATIONAL SECURITY. ALSO LETS NOT FORGET THAT THEY CONTROL THE OIL.
 
If at all we have to get foreign fighter jets it should be from Russia. Su57 is streets ahead of anything the west has to offer. Rafale vs not match our good old Su30 in performance. Top priority should be Tejas with Saturn engines not sloppy GE or Safran.
In an ideal world, yes, we should have gone with Su57.
But Russian manufacturing capability is in shambles...they're barely able tp manufacture jets for themselves due to war and the sanctions.

IAF, MoD and GOI...probably realized that Su57 will take much larger time to get ready and IAF cant wait. Other platforms like Gripen, Eurofighter etc arw dependent on US engine and as IAF is already using Rafale...it would be easier for them to absorb.

Plus, there is another factor of CAATSA. India simply cant afford to do that, and we have been trying to lure Safran to manufacture engine....going through France provided a middle path to avoid US sanctions and also not to fall in their trap.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
6,114
Messages
61,868
Members
4,817
Latest member
aryathesuperstar31
Back
Top