Russia's Su-57E Offer to India Includes Complete Customization with Indigenous Systems and Integration, Paralleling Development with AMCA Project

Russia's Su-57E Offer to India Includes Complete Customization with Indigenous Systems and Integration, Paralleling Development with AMCA Project


At the Aero India 2025 exposition, Russia has presented India with a detailed proposal for the domestic production of the Su-57E, the export version of Russia's fifth-generation stealth fighter.

This offer, communicated by Russia's state defence export agency, Rosoboronexport, and the United Aircraft Corporation (UAC), features a complete Transfer of Technology (ToT). This would grant India the capability to tailor the aircraft with domestically produced systems and subsystems.

A senior official highlighted during discussions that this proposal positions the Su-57E as a possible key element in India's defence modernization efforts. It also aligns with India's "Make in India" initiative by facilitating local manufacturing and fostering technological partnerships.

The Russian proposal includes the potential for local manufacturing of the Su-57E in India, possibly at the Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL) facility in Nashik, which previously handled production of the Su-30MKI.

This offer coincides with India's ongoing development of its own indigenous fifth-generation fighter, the AMCA. The AMCA is currently in the design phase, with production not anticipated until 2034-35. The Su-57E is being presented as a viable interim solution to address India's immediate fighter capability needs, while also potentially contributing technological advancements that could benefit the AMCA program.

A crucial element of the Russian offer is the comprehensive ToT, empowering India to adapt the Su-57E to its specific operational needs. Official stressed that the ToT would allow India to incorporate indigenous systems and subsystems, mirroring the approach adopted for the AMCA. This level of adaptability represents a considerable shift from conventional defence agreements, where foreign vendors frequently restrict modifications.

When questioned about India's ability to substitute Russian systems with domestically developed alternatives, the official confirmed Russia's willingness to accommodate further customization, although the precise scope of such alterations would necessitate in-depth negotiations.

"The ToT offer will enable India to customize the aircraft, potentially incorporating Indian-made systems and sub-components," the official stated. "Further discussions will be required to determine the specific modifications India desires, but Russia is receptive to such changes."

This openness to customization is a deliberate strategic approach by Russia to allay India's concerns regarding technological dependence and to ensure the Su-57E aligns with India's objectives of achieving self-reliance.

Likely areas for Indian customization could encompass avionics, electronic warfare systems, and weaponry. This would allow leveraging systems already in development for the AMCA, such as indigenous Active Electronically Scanned Array (AESA) radars, mission computers, and precision-guided munitions. Integrating these indigenous technologies not only enhances the Su-57E's capabilities but also contributes significantly to the growth of India's domestic defence industry.

The engine powering the Su-57E is a vital component of the proposal, directly influencing the aircraft's performance, stealth characteristics, and operational effectiveness.

The official confirmed that the engine currently included in the offer is the AL-41F-1S (also referred to as Izdeliye 117S). This is a well-established afterburning turbofan engine that powers the initial production series of the Su-57. The AL-41F-1S provides a dry thrust of 9 tonnes and an afterburning thrust of 14.5 tonnes, enabling the aircraft to reach supersonic speeds and providing enhanced maneuverability.

Regarding the more advanced AL-51 (Izdeliye 30) engine, specifically designed for the Su-57 and offering improved performance, including supercruise capability (maintaining supersonic speed without using afterburners), the official indicated that this engine remains in the testing phase and has not yet entered mass production.

"The AL-51 may not be available immediately, but it could be offered at a later stage once its development is complete and it is ready for production," the official explained.

The AL-51, boasting a higher thrust rating (11 tonnes dry and 17.5 tonnes with afterburner) and improved stealth features, such as serrated exhaust nozzles to minimize infrared and radar signatures, constitutes a substantial improvement over the AL-41F-1S.

Its eventual integration into the Su-57E could significantly bolster the aircraft's attractiveness, bringing it closer to meeting India's long-term requirements for a cutting-edge fifth-generation fighter.

The development of the AL-51 engine is being closely watched by defence analysts, as it represents a key step in Russia's efforts to field a truly fifth-generation fighter aircraft.
 
As soon as India inquires about some weapon system from the West or Israel, Russia promptly presents a counter-offer apparently superior in every respect. In the past, we bought the S-400 at an exorbitant price, buying the hype that it's a PAC-3 and THAAD killer. This is not true. The Su-57 is largely unknown, like the Chinese J-20 or J-35. The F-35, on the other hand, is tried and tested by many countries and passed muster. Lastly, the AL-41 is not a fifth-generation engine.
 
Su-57 is junk! India walked out of the joint development program coz Russia did not listen to its concerns regarding engine reliability and radar cross-section. They didn't even give access to the technical research! They just stole Indian money to develop it, and now they are offering ToT coz no one is buying their junk now!! 🤬
 
You think Russians are going to accept INR.
We are already trading with them in Rupees and Roubles for oil payments. The payment system within BRICS is not established, but they have been using a method using blockchain called "M Bridge," which would be used to make payments.

In other words, BRICS is not planning to create a new currency like the Euro or the $. A new currency called "unit" is going to be created, as it is just going to be an accounting unit updated in two places simultaneously: one in the Central Bank Ledger of the country and secondly in the ledger of the bank of origin of the transaction. The ledger entries, once posted, cannot be erased. The book entry currency, called the unit, will be posted on the ledger of the Central Bank of the receiving country via the counterparty's Central Bank along with the Bank of destination, which will then be converted into local currency. This is one method.

The second method involves payments to be made in gold directly.

There is also a third method, which India and other countries have been using successfully for making payments to countries banned by the West. Special Vostro accounts would be opened in the country's name, and deposits in local currency would be made as transactions are made. The other party would also open a Vostro account in India's name for the same purpose. When either party needs a settlement, the settlement would be done buying the local currency of the receiver.

In the case of Russia, the Russian Govt is keen on investing in large infrastructure projects in India. So, a special exemption is made for Russia alone in buying stake in large infrastructure projects, which will generate returns.
 
People who comment as Russian junk must understand the same junk is securing our boarders from cunning enemies since 70 years.
Su-57 is great opurtunity Russia was and is trusted partner for india by decades
Unless America a cunning and no reliability,
Unproven combat record of f-35 ,and specifically unstable minded Trump,also delayed supply of f-404 engines and asking ransome hiking amounts for f414 engines
America having no credibility by its nature how America thrown ukrain in the war by falls promises and how now retreating backword
Atleast not giving nato membership
No country having brain can't go for any crucial diffence deals with America
Russia given customised tot and accepted indigenous tech modifications for su-30.
now time to get new engine tech along with Russia is greatest opurtunity.
F-35 procurement kills AMCA Russia su-57 is a opurtunity to fast forward speed for amca
 
All said & done F35 too face lots of problems & as per USA agency it's availability rate is less than 60% there are cost overruns other technical ditches too though it's the best 5th generation aircraft today there will be no TOT not even any of our weapons electronics or radars integration & will come with riders like during war you need USA authorisation forget nuclear weapon delivery & even if ordered today first delivery is not coming before 2031 as there are order backlogs & life time maintenance costs are very very high which IAF may find difficult to sustain it's better going for SU57 with TOT local manufacturing etc though it is bit inferior to F35 & pvt sector should be involved for manufacturing
 
The IAF should acquire 4-6 squadrons each of Su-57 and F-35, study the aircraft, and then produce an upgraded Su-57 which has stealth, super manoeuvrability, super cruise capabilities with sensor fusion, computing power, and EW/radar capability of the F-35, using upgraded Indian-produced radars, supercomputers, EW, stealth materials, coatings, and especially an Indian-produced engine based on Izdeliye-30.
 
Sorry Putin. You can stop the efforts. How muchever enticing won't work this time.

Your buddy at the White House had a single stare at India and the trembling doesn't stop still.

So India is not gonna buy Su-57 even if you offer it for free. India is ordered to buy f-35 at an OBSCENELY AND FILTHILY HUGE PRICE.

So, stop wasting your energy.
 
I am onboard with this! Russia has always been an all weather ally ever since 1947.

I don’t trust the Americans one bit. What if the Democrats are back in 2028? They are always out to get us and always pro terrorists! They might withhold crucial parts and tech just to fuck with us!
 
Does this ToT includes Engine as well? If Yes, India should consider it rather than going behind F-35.
They might include some common parts from AL41 that are being used in AL51, but not the whole engine core because we are not willing to pay a high price because it's a new engine.
 
If you want a complete fifth generation fighter, loaded with powerfull radar, passive sensors, and hitech network centre warfare - go for f 35.
If you want a advanced 4.5 generation fighter which is better than rafale, f15, gripen and typhoon,go for su 57.

Don't commit to su57 if russia own airforce is not buying it.
With eye on China, usa maybe more lenient with f35 offer.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
4,199
Messages
43,194
Members
2,742
Latest member
sujith sudhakaran
Back
Top